Cimaise
Fundamentals

Agreed value or market value: what changes when you make a claim

·7 min read·The Cimaise team
Watercolour of a fortress — a work appraised when the policy is taken out
The appraisal, carried out when the policy is taken out, becomes part of the contract.

Two approaches to settlement stand opposed. One fixes the value beforehand, through appraisal; the other negotiates it afterwards, under pressure. As long as nothing happens, the difference is invisible. On the day of the loss, it is measured in tens of percentage points — and it decides what you actually receive.

Market value and agreed value: the two definitions

Market value is the price the work would have fetched on the market on the day of the loss, between an informed seller and buyer. It is only set after the loss, by the insurer's appraiser. Agreed value is the value the policyholder and the insurer accepted together when the policy was taken out, on the basis of an appraisal. It is written into the policy, work by work, and serves as the reference if a claim arises.

Between the two sit other notions that fuel the confusion:

NotionWho sets itWhenWhat it guarantees
Market valueThe insurer's appraiserAfter the lossA market estimate, open to dispute
Declared valueThe policyholder aloneAt inceptionA ceiling, not a settled value
Replacement valueThe appraiser, per the policyAfter the lossThe price of an equivalent item — rarely relevant for a unique work
Agreed valuePolicyholder and insurer, on appraisalAt inceptionThe amount paid, with no renegotiation

The distinction that most often catches people out: a declared value is not an agreed value. Declaring €50,000 for a painting proves nothing on the day of the loss; the insurer can still dispute the real value and, if you under-declared, apply the average clause (proportional reduction).

Market value: the estimate after the event

Under a standard home insurance policy, your works are "valuables" among others. When a claim arises, the insurer appoints its appraiser, who estimates the market value. That estimate comes at the worst possible moment — after the loss — and rests on debatable comparables, a shifting market rating and sometimes old invoices.

Three difficulties come up almost every time:

  • Proof. It is up to you to establish the existence, authenticity and condition of the work before the loss. Without dated photographs, invoices, a certificate or a condition report, the discussion starts from a very low point.
  • The market. An artist's rating varies with the period and the latest auction result. The insurer's appraiser will readily take the low estimate.
  • Limits. Most policies cap cover for valuables at a percentage of the contents sum insured. A serious collection almost always exceeds them — and you bear the excess. The details are in our article on the limits of home insurance for works of art.

Agreed value: the value fixed beforehand

An agreed-value policy reverses the logic. Each work is appraised at inception; the value retained is written into the policy. In the event of a total loss, that value is paid — as it stands, with no renegotiation. The appraisal is no longer a battleground after the event: it is part of the contract. It is the foundation of our all-risks agreed-value policy.

Under French law, property insurance follows the indemnity principle: the payout must not exceed the value of the insured item (French Insurance Code, Article L121-1). Agreed value does not get round this principle; it settles it in advance: the value of the work is established and accepted by both parties before any loss, instead of being disputed afterwards. Hence the importance of a serious, recent appraisal: it is what gives the stated value its strength. Our guide to appraisal for insurance explains who carries it out and what it contains.

Market value vs agreed value: side by side

CriterionHome insurance (market value)Agreed value
Basis of settlementNegotiated after the lossFixed in the policy, by appraisal
LimitsValuables cappedEach work at its full value
AppraisalAt your expense, after the eventArranged at inception
Burden of proofOn the policyholder, at the worst momentSettled at inception
Transit & loansRarely coveredNail-to-nail, continuously

Total loss, partial loss: what is paid

Agreed value applies in full in the event of a total loss: theft with no recovery, destruction. The stated value is paid.

In the event of a partial loss — a torn canvas, a broken frame, water damage — the policy covers restoration by a qualified conservator. But a restored work is often worth less than before, even when the work is successful. That is the purpose of depreciation cover after restoration: the loss in value is indemnified against the agreed value, on top of the cost of restoration. Without a reference value fixed in advance, that depreciation would be almost impossible to quantify.

What it changes in practice

Take an oil painting appraised at €80,000, lost in transit. Under standard home insurance: a valuables limit often around €15,000 to €20,000, transit rarely covered, and a value to prove, invoice in hand. With agreed value: €80,000 paid, because that is the value written into the policy and nail-to-nail cover protected the journey.

Same example, this time a partial loss: the canvas is damaged, restored, then valued at €60,000 after treatment. With agreed value and depreciation cover, the policy pays for the restoration and indemnifies the €20,000 loss. With market value, you would first have to agree on what the work was worth before — exactly the debate agreed value avoids.

A collection is insured the way it was built: piece by piece. That is the whole purpose of our policy for collectors and private clients.

Keeping an agreed value accurate over time

An agreed value is not set in stone. It has to follow the artist's market and the way your collection evolves:

  • Periodic review: update appraisals every three to five years as a rule, more often for an artist whose market moves fast.
  • An endorsement for each acquisition: a new piece is covered provisionally under new acquisitions cover, then added at its value.
  • Beware of undervaluation: an agreed value left at its level of ten years ago offers poor protection. Our article on underinsurance and revaluation explains how to avoid it.

The premium depends on the value insured, the nature of the works and the storage conditions; orders of magnitude are set out in our article on the cost of fine art insurance.

Key takeaways

  • Agreed value is set before any loss, by appraisal: no debate at settlement.
  • A merely declared value is not an agreed value: it remains open to dispute.
  • The valuables limits of a home insurance policy are almost always exceeded by a real collection.
  • In a partial loss, agreed value is the basis for indemnifying depreciation.
  • Agreed value is reviewed: with the market, and with each acquisition or new appraisal.

FAQ

What is the difference between agreed value and market value?

Agreed value is set before any loss, on appraisal, and accepted by the insurer: it is paid as it stands in a total loss. Market value is estimated after the loss by the insurer's appraiser, based on the market at the time, and remains open to dispute.

Can the agreed value change over time?

Yes. It is reviewed periodically in line with the market, and an endorsement updates it with each new acquisition or new appraisal.

Does every work need an appraisal?

Above a unit value threshold set in the policy, yes. Below it, a documented inventory — photographs, invoices, provenance — is generally enough.

Are declared value and agreed value the same thing?

No. A declared value is an amount stated by the policyholder, without appraisal: the insurer can dispute it after the loss. Agreed value rests on an appraisal accepted at inception.

Is a work covered in transit?

Yes, nail-to-nail cover protects the work continuously, including during transit, loans and exhibitions, from the moment it comes off the wall until it is hung again.

Does agreed value necessarily cost more?

Not necessarily. The premium depends on the real risk — the nature of the works, storage conditions, location. Agreed value above all secures the settlement, with no debate when a claim arises.

Have your collection's value agreed up front.