Cimaise
Appraisal

Art appraisers and insurance appraisals: a practical guide

·8 min read·The Cimaise team
Old Master work — the kind of piece whose value is set by appraisal
The appraisal establishes, at inception, the value stated in the policy.

Even before choosing a cover, one question decides everything: what is the work worth? On an agreed value basis, the answer does not wait for a loss — it is set at inception, by an appraiser, and written in black and white into the policy. The appraisal is therefore not an administrative formality: it is the document that will determine, to the euro, what you receive on the day a canvas burns, disappears or breaks. Neglecting it means building your protection on an approximate value.

Why the appraisal determines your compensation

A fine art insurance policy on an agreed value basis rests on a simple principle: the value of each work is established before any loss, by appraisal, and then written into the policy. In the event of a total loss, this value is paid as it stands, without renegotiation. The appraisal is therefore the input that drives the whole mechanism — an agreed value policy without a serious appraisal is an empty shell.

By contrast, a policy that compensates on a market value basis defers the valuation until after the event: the insurer appoints its appraiser once the damage has occurred, at the worst possible moment for you, on the basis of debatable comparables. We explain this difference in logic in our article on the difference between agreed value and market value. In essence, remember this: a solid appraisal moves the discussion about value away from the time of the loss — when you are in a weak position — to the time of inception, when everything can be negotiated calmly.

This is why the appraisal is the foundation of our all risks policy on an agreed value basis: without it, the promise of compensation without debate has nothing to stand on.

Who can carry out an appraisal for insurance

Not every estimate carries the same weight with an insurer. What it expects is an independent, written and substantiated opinion from a professional whose job this is. Several profiles qualify:

  • The fine art appraiser, often a member of a professional body or trade association, sometimes approved by insurance companies. They write a detailed appraisal report, with a reasoned insurance value.
  • The auctioneer (*commissaire-priseur* in France, an operator of voluntary auction sales), well placed to value a work in light of recent auction results.
  • The gallery or dealer representing an artist, legitimately able to establish the value of pieces in its primary market — useful in particular for contemporary art.
  • The auction house, which provides estimates with a view to a sale and can supply a reference value.

One point to watch: the insurer favours an appraisal that is independent of any commercial interest. An estimate provided by whoever sold you the work may be accepted, but an outside opinion carries more weight, especially above a certain value threshold. Another essential distinction: authenticating a work (establishing who made it) and valuing it (setting its market value) are two different tasks. An insurance appraisal concerns value; it relies on an attribution assumed to be established, without guaranteeing it.

What an appraisal report contains

A report that an insurer can use goes well beyond a figure. It serves as proof of the existence, description and value of each item — three decisive elements on the day of a loss, particularly in the case of theft, when the work is no longer there to speak for itself. A complete report generally includes:

  • The identification of the work: artist (or attribution), title, date, technique, support, dimensions, presence and location of the signature, inventory number.
  • The provenance and history: chain of ownership, exhibitions, publications, any certificates.
  • The condition: known restorations, alterations, weaknesses.
  • A photographic record: overall view, reverse of the work, details, signature.
  • The value adopted and its basis (insurance value or replacement value), with the comparables that justify it.
  • The date of the appraisal and the identity of the signatory.

This file has a useful second life: it feeds the collection inventory and makes loans, shipping and, when the time comes, succession easier. Well kept, it saves valuable time at every stage.

How the appraiser sets the value: the criteria that count

The value of a work is not fixed: it results from the meeting between characteristics specific to the piece and the state of a market. The appraiser cross-checks several criteria, whose weight varies according to the nature of the work.

CriterionWhat the appraiser looks atEffect on value
Attribution / authenticityCertainty about the artist, signature, certificatesDecisive: any doubt weighs heavily downwards
RarityUnique piece, limited series, sought-after periodStrengthens value if supply is narrow
ConditionRestorations, alterations, weaknessesHeavy restoration can cause lasting depreciation
Provenance and exhibition historyPrestigious collections, catalogues, museumsFine provenance adds value and reassures
Format and techniqueSupport, dimensions, mediumInfluences value according to the codes of the artist's market
Market value and comparablesRecent sales results, market trendAnchors the estimate in actual observed prices

Two works by the same artist can therefore show very different values depending on their condition, provenance or subject. This is why an estimate "by the square metre" or a simple extrapolation from an old purchase price is not enough: only an examination of the piece, backed by comparables, holds up.

Insurance value, market value, replacement value

Three expressions are in circulation, and confusing them is costly. Market value is the price a work would fetch on sale, under market conditions — it is the basis of standard policies, estimated after the loss. Replacement value is what you would have to pay to acquire an equivalent work from a dealer: it includes the seller's margin and therefore sits above the "hammer" market value. The insurance value adopted on an agreed value basis is most often aligned with this replacement value, so that the compensation genuinely allows you to rebuild your assets.

In practice, ask the appraiser on what basis they are valuing. The same canvas might be worth, for example, €60,000 at market value and more at replacement value once the market margin is included. Insuring on the wrong basis means finding yourself, after a total loss, unable to buy a comparable work.

How often to update the appraisal

An appraisal does not last for ever. The market moves, prices rise or fall back, and a value fixed ten years ago may leave you underinsured without your knowing it. Underinsurance has a direct effect: compensation is capped at the stated value, whatever the real value on the day. Conversely, over-declaring does not earn you more — compensation does not exceed the loss — but it increases the premium.

The right frequency depends mainly on how volatile the market segment is.

Type of workRecommended updateWhy
Contemporary art by a living artistRoughly every 2 yearsShifting market value, sensitive primary market
Established modern artEvery 3 to 5 yearsMore stable values, but closely followed
Old Masters, classical artEvery 5 to 10 yearsSlow market, variations less frequent
New acquisitionImmediately, by endorsementTo cover the piece as soon as it arrives
After major restorationAs soon as the work is completedThe value may have changed

Beyond the calendar, certain events trigger an update: an acquisition, a record sale that redefines an artist's market value, a landmark exhibition, a restoration. A specialist broker helps you keep track and adjust values by endorsement, without waiting for the annual renewal. This is something we follow closely for the collectors and private individuals we work with.

How much does an appraisal cost, and how is it charged?

The cost depends on the number of works, their complexity and the research required. Three methods of charging coexist:

  • A flat fee per work or per batch, common when a few pieces need valuing.
  • A percentage of the appraised value, often on a sliding scale — the rate falls as the overall value rises. For a large collection, this percentage generally remains a modest fraction of the value (by way of example, well below 1%).
  • A daily rate, for a full on-site inventory.

Compared with what is at stake — securing compensation that matches the value of your assets — the cost of an appraisal is marginal. It is also an investment that serves several times over: inception, updates, loans, succession. Before committing, you can request a quote for your collection; we will then point you towards the appraisal arrangement best suited to its nature and value.

FAQ

Do I need to have every work in my collection appraised?

Not systematically. Above a unit value threshold set in the policy, an individual appraisal is generally required. Below it, a documented inventory — photos, invoices, provenance — is usually enough to establish the agreed value.

Is a purchase invoice enough to prove value?

It helps, but is not enough on its own, especially if it is old. The market may have moved, and the price paid does not always reflect the current replacement value. A recent appraisal remains the most solid reference in the event of a loss.

Does an insurance appraisal authenticate the work?

No. Valuing a work and authenticating its maker are two separate processes. An insurance appraisal concerns value and relies on an attribution assumed to be established; authentication is a matter for expert committees or specialist estates and rights holders.

Who pays for the appraisal, me or the insurer?

As a rule, the appraisal prior to inception is paid for by the owner. In the event of a loss, the insurer appoints and pays its own appraiser. A broker can direct you to recognised appraisers and negotiate the terms of their engagement.

My appraisal is ten years old: is it still valid?

It probably needs updating. For Old Master art, an older appraisal may remain relevant; for contemporary art, ten years is enough to shift market value significantly. If in doubt, have the values checked before renewing your policy.

Have your collection's value agreed up front.