Cimaise
Coverage

Underinsuring works of art: how to avoid the average clause

·7 min read·The Cimaise team
Study of birds, antique plate — a collection piece whose insurance value moves with the market
A work's value moves; the sum that insures it must keep pace.

A collection appreciates; the sum that insures it often stays at the figure set on the day the policy was taken out. A gap quietly opens up between the two. It only comes to light when there is a claim, when the insurer compares the declared value with the actual value of the work. This mismatch has a name — underinsurance — and so does its penalty: the average clause, or proportional reduction of the indemnity.

Underinsurance, a dormant risk

A work is underinsured as soon as the sum insured under the policy is lower than the actual value of the property on the day of the loss. As long as nothing happens, this shortfall costs nothing and goes unnoticed: the premium has been paid, the certificate is on file, everything looks in order. The problem only appears at the worst moment — at settlement.

Works of art are particularly exposed. The value of a painting, a sculpture or a group of works shifts over time, almost always upwards, whereas the sum written into the policy does not move on its own. A policy taken out eight years ago on the price levels of the time now insures a work that may well be worth twice as much. The policyholder believes they are 100% covered; in reality they are covered at 50%.

The average clause, worked through

In France, the mechanism is set out in Article L121-5 of the Code des assurances (the French Insurance Code): if, on the day of the loss, the value of the insured property exceeds the sum insured, "the insured is deemed to remain their own insurer for the excess". In other words, you become co-insurer of the undeclared portion, and you bear a proportional share of every loss.

The calculation is simple: indemnity = loss × (sum insured ÷ actual value). Let us take an example. A group of works declared at €40,000 is actually worth €80,000 on the day of the loss. An escape of water damages one piece, with the loss estimated at €20,000. The coverage ratio is only 50%, and the indemnity follows:

ItemAmount (illustrative example)
Declared sum insured€40,000
Actual value on the day of the loss€80,000
Loss suffered€20,000
Coverage ratio (40,000 ÷ 80,000)50%
Indemnity actually paid€10,000

Half of the loss remains at your expense, even though the loss is only partial and the cover appeared to be in place. One important point: the rule applies automatically, "unless otherwise agreed". It is this proviso that opens the way to a remedy, as we will see below.

Why the value of a collection drifts

Underinsurance is almost never a glaring oversight. It sets in gradually, as the collection evolves.

  • Prices rise. The market re-rates an artist, a period, a medium. An acquisition made at the right time can see its replacement value increase significantly within a few years.
  • The collection grows. Each new acquisition comes into the home but not always into the policy. Without an endorsement, the piece remains undeclared.
  • The work changes status. A successful restoration, a confirmed attribution, a documented provenance: all events that raise the insurance value.
  • Art market inflation. Across an entire collection, a general rise of a few points a year is enough, compounded, to open a gap of tens of thousands of euros over a decade.

The sum insured, meanwhile, remains a static figure until someone updates it. Revaluation exists precisely to correct this mismatch between a value that moves and a figure that stands still.

Agreed value: the remedy for the average clause

This is where the type of policy makes all the difference. Under an agreed value policy, each work is appraised when the policy is taken out and the value retained is written into the policy in black and white. That value is deemed accurate between the parties: after a loss, the insurer cannot claim that the work was worth more in order to apply the average clause. The "otherwise agreed" provided for by the law is exactly that.

This approach is the foundation of our all risks agreed value policy for works of art. By contrast, a work tucked into a standard home insurance policy is still assessed at market value, estimated after the event — fertile ground for underinsurance and "valuables" limits. We cover this shift in detail in our article on agreed value versus market value.

One point deserves to be made clearly, because it counters a common misconception: agreed value neutralises the average clause, but it does not exempt you from keeping the value up to date. A value agreed in 2018 protects… the 2018 value. If prices have doubled since, the indemnity for a total loss will be capped at the agreed amount — with no reduction, admittedly, but with no uplift either. Hence the next step.

Revaluing your sum insured: the method

Revaluation is not an anxious annual ritual; it is simple good practice, built on four habits.

  1. Keep a living inventory. Photographs, invoices, certificates, provenance, dimensions: one file per work, updated with every movement. It is the basis of any appraisal and the first piece of evidence in the event of a claim.
  2. Have works reappraised periodically. Above a certain per-item value threshold, a reappraisal every three to five years — or after any notable market event — brings the agreed value back in line with reality.
  3. Declare every acquisition. An endorsement adds the new piece to the policy, at its value, without waiting for the annual renewal. In between, a new acquisitions clause often covers incoming works up to a set limit.
  4. Index the whole collection. For large collections, an indexation clause adjusts the overall sum insured, alongside piece-by-piece reappraisals.

The process works best when framed with a broker: this is the role of the appraisal we describe in our guide to appraising a work for insurance, and one of the points we systematically review with the collectors and private clients we work with. A policy that is well calibrated today will not stay that way on its own in five years' time.

Key takeaways

  • Underinsurance is silent: it only reveals itself at claim time, as a pro rata reduction of the indemnity.
  • The average clause (Article L121-5) reduces the indemnity in the ratio of sum insured ÷ actual value — half covered, half paid by you.
  • Agreed value neutralises this rule, but does not exempt you from keeping the value up to date.
  • A living inventory, periodic reappraisal, an endorsement for every acquisition: revaluation is good practice, not a chore.

FAQ

What is the average clause?

It is the mechanism, provided for in France by Article L121-5 of the Code des assurances, that reduces the indemnity when the sum insured is lower than the actual value on the day of the loss. The indemnity is calculated pro rata: loss × (sum insured ÷ actual value). It applies automatically, unless otherwise agreed.

Does agreed value really eliminate underinsurance?

It neutralises the penalty: because the value written into the policy is deemed accurate, the insurer cannot apply the average clause to agreed-value works. However, if that agreed value has not been updated, the indemnity will be capped at the agreed amount, even if the work is worth more today.

How often should you revalue the sum insured on your collection?

A reappraisal every three to five years is a good rhythm for valuable pieces, supplemented by an update after any notable event: a sharp change in price levels, a restoration, a new attribution. Acquisitions, for their part, should be declared as they happen, without waiting for renewal.

Is a new acquisition covered automatically?

Rarely in full. Many policies include a new acquisitions clause that covers incoming works for a set period and up to a limit, while the position is regularised. Beyond that, only a declaration by endorsement covers the piece at its full value.

What happens if the declared value is too high?

Overinsurance brings no benefit: the indemnity remains capped at the actual loss, because insurance cannot be a source of profit. You would simply have paid a premium on an overstated sum insured. The aim is therefore accuracy — neither above nor below the actual value.

Have your collection's value agreed up front.