Cimaise
Comparison

What is the best fine art insurance?

No insurer is “better” than all the others — there is the right policy for your profile. Whether you are looking for art insurance for a collection, a few paintings or other objets d'art, the foundation of serious fine art insurance is always the same: an all-risks, agreed-value policy, nail-to-nail. Here is an overview of the French market, the criteria that matter, indicative prices — and how a broker picks the best offer for you.

The short answer

The best fine art insurance is an all-risks policy on an agreed-value basis, suited to your profession and the value of your collection. Rather than choosing an insurer on your own, put the specialist insurers in competition — which is precisely the role of a broker.

01

Home insurance or a specialist policy?

This is the first decision. For a real collection, a dedicated art policy changes everything: the basis of settlement, the limits and the cover for transit.

Criterion
Standard home insurance
Specialist policy (agreed value)
Basis of settlement
Market value, argued over after the claim
Agreed value, set in the policy by appraisal
Limits
Valuables capped (% of contents)
Each work insured for its full value
Transit, loans, exhibitions
Rarely covered
Nail-to-nail, continuously
Depreciation after restoration
Not taken into account
Covered
Appraisal
At your expense, after the event
Arranged when the policy is taken out
02

The specialist insurers

A handful of companies dominate fine art insurance in France. Each has its strengths and its entry threshold — here is an indicative guide.

Insurer
Positioning
Indicative threshold
Best suited to
Hiscox — Fine Art
Global specialist. All risks, worldwide cover including transit, agreed value, automatic new acquisitions (30%), loans, legal protection.
€5,000 → €500,000 direct; above that through a broker
Collectors, businesses
AXA XL — Art One / Private Collections
Long-standing player, formerly AXA Art, merged into AXA XL at the end of 2019. Teams of experts and art historians. “Art One” = all risks with no deductible for modest collections.
from ~€20,000 (Art One < €500,000)
Private individuals, galleries, institutions
Arte Generali
Generali's dedicated art brand: a modular offer plus prevention and conservation services.
often geared to ≥ €500,000
Collectors, professionals
Chubb — Masterpiece
Premium “agreed value” offer, geared to very high-net-worth clients.
≈ €100,000 and above
Major private collections
Albingia — Objet d'art
French insurer: “artistic value” cover supplemented by “technical” (working order) cover, useful for contemporary works.
tailor-made
Contemporary works, professionals
Allianz — Arts & Collections
A solution that can be added to a home insurance policy, convenient if you are already a customer.
from ~€10,000
Existing private customers

An indicative, non-exhaustive overview of the French market, for information only — thresholds, cover and rates change and vary by profile. Cimaise is not affiliated with any of these brands: as a broker, we put them in competition to build your policy. Other insurers (Helvetia, Lloyd's…) are also active in this market.

03

Insurer direct or broker?

An insurer only offers its own policies. A broker puts several specialist insurers in competition, negotiates the clauses and gives you a single point of contact. Beyond a few tens of thousands of euros, the difference shows in both the cover and the price.

CimaiseUs
Specialist art broker — puts specialist insurers (and Lloyd's) in competition, builds a tailor-made agreed-value policy, and gives you a single point of contact from appraisal to claim.
Verspieren
High-end broker: worldwide nail-to-nail cover, agreed value, a dedicated expert and 24/7 claims handling, for exceptional collections.
Gras Savoye (WTW) · Diot-SIACI
Large brokers with art and special-risks departments, mainly geared to institutions and major estates.
Art et Assurances · La Compagnie des Arts
More accessible brokers/specialists, geared to emerging collections (from ~€5,000).
—

The comparison at a glance

Criterion
Home insurance
Specialist insurer
Through a broker
Agreed value (set before any claim)
✕
✓
✓
Nail-to-nail / transit & loans
✕
✓
✓
Insurers put in competition
✕
✕
✓
Negotiation of clauses & deductibles
✕
~
✓
Single point of contact (appraisal → claim)
~
~
✓
Access to several markets (incl. Lloyd's)
✕
✕
✓
05

How much does it cost?

The premium depends mainly on the insured value, how the works are kept, their location and the extensions chosen. As a guide, it usually falls between 0.3% and 1.2% a year. An appraisal, when required, is charged separately.

Insured value
Indicative annual premium
Under €50,000
≈ 0.8 – 1.2% / year
€50,000 – €250,000
≈ 0.5 – 0.8% / year
€250,000 – €1m
≈ 0.4 – 0.5% / year
Over €1m
≈ 0.3 – 0.4% / year (on quotation)
06

How Cimaise picks the best for you

We start from your collection and your profession, have whatever needs appraising appraised, then consult the specialist insurers — in France and at Lloyd's. You receive the best agreed-value offer for your situation, reviewed line by line.

A collection of artworks hung in a gallery room

Frequently asked questions

What is the best fine art insurance?
There is no single “best” insurer: the best policy is an all-risks, agreed-value policy chosen according to your profile (collector, gallery, artist, institution) and the value of your collection. A specialist broker's job is to put the specialist insurers in competition and secure the best offer for your situation.
Should I go through a broker or buy direct?
Once your art holdings exceed a few tens of thousands of euros, a broker becomes strategic: they put several specialist insurers in competition, negotiate the clauses and deductibles, and give you a single point of contact from appraisal to claim.
How much does fine art insurance cost?
As a guide, the annual premium is often between 0.3% and 1.2% of the insured value, depending on the value of the collection, its location, how it is kept and the extensions chosen. An appraisal, when required, is charged separately.
Is home insurance enough for my artworks?
Rarely. Home insurance caps “valuables” at a percentage of your contents — almost always exceeded by a real collection — settles on a market value argued over after the event, and covers transit poorly. A specialist agreed-value policy removes these limits.
Hiscox, AXA XL, Albingia… which should I choose?
It depends on your profile and the value of your collection: each insurer has its strengths and entry thresholds. Rather than deciding alone, let a broker compare these offers for you and build the best-suited policy.
Compare the specialist insurers — without spending your days on it.