Cimaise
Appraisal

Artwork condition reports: the proof that secures your claim

·8 min read·The Cimaise team
Close-up detail of an Old Master painting under examination — the condition report records every alteration before a move

A scratch on the corner of a frame, a tiny blister in the varnish, a chipped plinth corner: when a work comes back from an exhibition, these minor damages almost always raise the same question, left without a clear answer for lack of proof — were they there before it left? The condition report exists precisely to settle that doubt. It is a dated, photographed and precise record of a work's condition at a given moment, the one that makes it possible, in the event of a claim, to show that an alteration really did occur during transit, a loan or storage — and not before. Without this document, genuine damage can go uncompensated simply because no one can prove when it appeared.

The condition report: definition and real purpose

The condition report — *constat d'état* in French — describes the physical state of a work: its nature, dimensions and technique, but above all every visible alteration at the time of examination. Craquelure, losses, overpainting, oxidation, impacts, stains, play in a joint: everything is recorded, located and dated, backed up by reference photographs.

There is nothing bureaucratic about this document. It serves as evidence. Transit is the riskiest moment in the life of a work, and most compensation disputes are not about whether damage exists, but about when it appeared. A condition report drawn up before departure, followed by a second one on arrival, makes it possible to compare point by point and isolate what has changed. If there is a disagreement with the insurer, this comparison shifts the burden of proof: it is no longer up to the owner to show that the work was intact — the document attests to it.

It must be clearly distinguished from a valuation. One describes the physical condition, the other estimates the market value. The two complement each other but are not interchangeable: a work can be perfectly appraised as to its value and yet be indefensible in the event of breakage, for lack of a condition report documenting its integrity on departure. For the second side of the equation, our guide to having a work of art appraised for insurance explains the valuation process.

What a complete condition report contains

A serious report is not just a few photos taken on a phone. It follows a rigorous template, reproducible from one examination to the next so that the comparison is meaningful:

  • Identification: title, artist, date, technique, support, precise dimensions, inventory or edition number, signature and inscriptions on the reverse.
  • Description of the general condition: integrity of the structure, the support, the paint layer, the frame or the plinth.
  • Record of alterations: each defect located (often on a diagram or annotated photo) and characterised — old or recent, stable or developing.
  • Photographic coverage: front, back, details of vulnerable areas, edges, reverse of the frame, under raking light to reveal surface relief.
  • Conditions of the examination: date, place, person who carried out the report, equipment used, light level.

The same document is filled in once at packing (departure report) and a second time when the crate is opened (arrival report). It is this pair, not a single report, that protects you in the event of a claim.

Condition report, appraisal and inventory: not to be confused

Three documents circulate in the vocabulary of art insurance and are regularly confused. The table below sets out their respective roles — the uses described are given as an illustrative example, as each policy may organise how they fit together differently.

DocumentWhat it establishesWhenRole in the event of a claim
Condition reportThe physical condition of the work on a given dateBefore/after each moveProve when damage appeared
ValuationThe market value of the workAt inception, then periodicallySet the sum insured
InventoryThe list and identity of the collectionOngoing, kept up to dateProve ownership and the scope of cover

These three documents form a coherent documentary foundation. The inventory says *what you own*, the appraisal *how much it is worth*, the condition report *what state it was in*. For keeping the first, our article on inventorying and documenting a collection completes the picture. In practice, a robust insurance file relies on all three, each covering the blind spots of the others.

When a condition report becomes essential

A report does not need to be drawn up for every work at all times. It becomes decisive as soon as a work changes hands, location or environment:

  • Before any transit, domestic or international, at packing and again at unpacking.
  • For a loan to an exhibition: the loan agreement almost always makes it an obligation, borne by the borrower.
  • Before and after restoration, to distinguish the initial condition from the intervention and any consequences it may have.
  • On entering and leaving storage or a consignment sale.
  • At an auction or during a transaction, to protect both buyer and seller.

These are precisely the situations in which responsibility passes from one party to another — and therefore those in which undocumented damage turns into a dispute. Professionals in the sector, particularly in art sales and shipping, make it a systematic practice, because their business consists of constantly moving high-value pieces. The condition report fits naturally with nail-to-nail cover, which follows the work from the wall it leaves to the wall it arrives at: the cover insures the risk, the report proves the damage.

What a good report changes when a claim arises

The day a work comes back damaged, the claim turns on details. The insurer seeks to establish three things: that damage exists, when it appeared and how extensive it is. A well-made condition report answers the first two in one go.

Take an illustrative example. A collector lends a canvas to a retrospective. On its return, a two-centimetre tear appears at the bottom right. Without a departure report, the borrower can argue that the tear was already there; the matter gets bogged down, the joint appraisal drags on, compensation is delayed. With a photographed departure report showing the area intact and an arrival report documenting the tear, the case is made in minutes: the damage occurred during the loan, so liability and cover apply. The difference is not theoretical — it is often the difference between a swift settlement and a refusal.

Once the damage is proven, the compensation must still rest on an undisputed value. This is where the all risks policy on an agreed value basis comes in: the value of the work is fixed by mutual agreement before any loss, on the basis of an appraisal, and is not reopened at the time of settlement. The report proves the damage; the agreed value quantifies the compensation. For the detailed steps to follow after an incident, our guide on how to make a claim for a work of art describes what to do as soon as the damage is discovered.

Who carries out the report, and how to give it weight

A condition report only carries evidential weight if its author and method are credible. Depending on what is at stake, it may be drawn up by a conservator-restorer, a curator, a registrar, an appraiser or a specialist art shipper trained in this exercise. For a high-value piece, the involvement of a qualified professional — ideally independent of the parties — significantly strengthens the document.

A few habits make it more robust:

  1. Date and sign each report, clearly identifying who carried it out and under what conditions.
  2. Photograph systematically, with a scale and a colour reference where possible, and keep the original, unedited files.
  3. Use the same template on departure and arrival, so the comparison is immediate.
  4. Keep everything together with the rest of the file — invoices, certificates, valuation, provenance — in a safe place and, ideally, as a digital copy stored away from where the collection is kept.

These precautions cost almost nothing compared with what they protect. Before moving a valuable work, having a specialist broker review how the loan agreement, the cover and the condition report fit together avoids blind spots: a simple fine art insurance quote lets you check that every part of the file is in place before the work leaves its wall.

FAQ

Is a condition report mandatory to insure a work?

No, it is not a legal requirement for taking out cover. But it becomes essential as soon as a work is shipped or lent: without one, proving the origin and date of damage is very difficult, which can block or reduce compensation. Loan agreements almost always require one in any case.

What is the difference between a condition report and an appraisal?

The condition report describes the physical state of the work on a specific date; the appraisal estimates its market value. One serves to prove damage, the other to set the sum insured. They complement each other and are not interchangeable.

Who should carry out the condition report?

Depending on what is at stake, a conservator-restorer, a curator, a registrar, an appraiser or a specialist art shipper trained in the exercise. For a valuable piece, a qualified professional independent of the parties gives the document considerably greater evidential weight.

Is a report needed both on departure and on arrival?

Yes, that is the whole principle. It is the comparison between the departure report and the arrival report that isolates what changed during the move. A single report, with nothing to compare it against, loses most of its usefulness in a dispute.

Are photos enough to serve as a condition report?

Photos are a key element, but not sufficient on their own. A report combines dated images with a written, located description of the alterations, a precise identification of the work and the conditions of the examination. It is this structured whole, not the photos alone, that constitutes proof.

Have your collection's value agreed up front.