Cimaise
Fundamentals

Insuring decorative arts and collectible furniture

·7 min read·The Cimaise team
Drawing room furnished with antique furniture and decorative art objects — a collection to insure on an agreed-value basis
Furniture, porcelain and decorative objects: a collection insured piece by piece.

A stamped commode, a pair of Louis XV armchairs, a Sèvres porcelain service, a gilt-bronze chandelier: taken together, these objects are often worth more than the paintings hanging above them. Yet they almost always sit in the "contents" line of a home insurance policy, compensated for breakage like a mass-produced sofa. The day one of them breaks, comes apart in transit or disappears, the gap between what it was worth and what the insurer pays out can run into tens of thousands of euros.

What the decorative arts cover

The decorative arts form a broad family, and that is precisely what makes them hard to insure properly. They include antique and collectible furniture — stamped, inlaid with marquetry, signed by a cabinetmaker — but also ceramics and porcelain, glass and crystal, goldsmiths' work and silver, bronzes, clocks and timepieces, carpets and tapestries, lighting, and display-cabinet objects.

These pieces share three traits that matter to an insurer. They are often fragile, sometimes extremely so: a porcelain vase or an engraved glass cannot be "restored" the way a canvas can. Their value depends on fine criteria — attribution, maker's stamp, condition, provenance, completeness of a service or a pair. And their prices move: 18th-century "brown furniture" went through difficult years while 20th-century design soared. A policy that ignores these particularities compensates poorly, or not at all.

Why home insurance protects them poorly

In a comprehensive home insurance policy, your decorative arts are lost within the contents sum insured and treated as "valuables". Three limits add up.

First, compensation is based on market value, estimated after the loss: the insurer appoints its own loss adjuster, who uses the price the object would have fetched on the market on the day of the damage. Old invoice, fluctuating prices, debatable comparables — the discussion begins at the worst possible moment, when the piece is already lost. Then come the caps: "valuables" cover is almost always limited to a percentage of the contents, quickly exceeded by a genuine collection. Finally, suitable cover is missing: transport, house moves, accidental breakage and depreciation after restoration are rarely covered as standard.

A dedicated policy reverses this logic. That is the purpose of an all risks policy on an agreed-value basis: each significant piece is appraised when the policy is taken out, its value written into the policy, and the whole collection covered "all risks except exclusions" rather than against a closed list of events.

Agreed value applied to objects

For a piece of furniture or an object, agreed value changes everything, because these pieces are hard to revalue once damaged or lost. The value is set beforehand, by an appraiser, and paid as is in the event of a total loss — with no renegotiation. We explain this mechanism in our article on agreed value versus market value.

You still need to set the right value. For decorative arts, the appraisal relies on concrete elements:

  • Attribution and signature: a cabinetmaker's stamp, a silversmith's hallmark or a factory mark can move a piece from one tier to another.
  • Condition and previous restorations: a remade marquetry top, retouched gilding or a reattached missing part all weigh on value.
  • Provenance: an old sale catalogue, a prestigious collection or an antique dealer's invoice strengthen the valuation. This is the role of a well-documented insurance appraisal.
  • Completeness: an incomplete service or a broken-up pair is worth far less than the whole.

The specific risks of furniture and objects

Each family has its vulnerabilities, and that is where the quality of a policy is decided.

Object familyMain riskPoint to check in the policy
Antique furniture, marquetryHumidity, wood-boring insects, knocks in transitExclusion of gradual deterioration; breakage and house-move cover
Porcelain, glass, crystalAccidental breakage, irreparable lossAccidental breakage cover genuinely included
Silver, goldsmiths' workTheft, break-inSecurity measures required are appropriate
Clocks, gilt bronzesImpact, mechanism wear, depreciationDistinction between insured damage and excluded maintenance
Carpets, tapestriesLight, moths, water damageConservation and storage conditions

Two exclusions appear everywhere and are worth understanding. Gradual deterioration — progressive wear, woodworm, oxidation, the action of light — is never covered: insurance covers the accident, not a lack of maintenance. And routine maintenance of a mechanism, gilding or varnish remains your responsibility. The line between sudden damage (insured) and gradual deterioration (excluded) is often the real issue in a claim.

Pairs, sets and depreciation: value traps

Decorative art objects are rarely thought of as single items. A pair of vases, armchairs or candelabra is worth more together than the sum of its two parts. If one is destroyed, the surviving piece loses part of its value: this is the logic of the pair and set clause, which compensates for the loss of value of the survivor, not just the lost item.

Another pitfall: a restored piece does not always regain its value. A reglued piece of furniture, a riveted porcelain or retouched gilding can retain residual depreciation despite a perfect restoration. A good policy compensates this loss of value on top of the cost of the work — a subject we cover in our guide to depreciation after restoration.

Shipping, house moves and loans

Decorative arts travel: a house move, a loan for an exhibition, a round trip to a conservator or a gilder. These are high-risk moments — most porcelain breakages and furniture accidents happen during handling. Nail-to-nail cover protects the object continuously, including during these movements, from its original location until its return. A home insurance policy, by contrast, usually stops at the walls of the home.

For a serious collection, packing and transport by fine art shipping professionals are not a luxury but a condition of cover. A common example: a porcelain service shipped without a compartmented crate and broken on the way may be refused on the grounds of inadequate packing. The way you prepare the move is part of the insured risk.

Insuring your collection of objects properly: the approach

The process is simpler than it seems, and it applies to an enthusiast as much as to a major collection.

  • Make an inventory: photograph each piece, note dimensions, materials, stamps and hallmarks, and gather invoices and provenance.
  • Have significant pieces appraised, above a per-item value threshold set in the policy.
  • Choose agreed value for the objects that carry the most weight in the collection.
  • Review regularly, in line with the market and with each new acquisition.

This is exactly the support we offer as part of insurance for collectors and private clients: cover that follows the collection as it has been built, piece by piece, rather than a line buried in a home insurance policy.

FAQ

Are my art objects already covered by my home insurance?

Partly, and often poorly. They fall under "valuables" cover, capped at a percentage of the contents and compensated at market value after the loss. A serious collection almost always exceeds these caps.

Is accidental breakage of porcelain compensated?

Only if accidental breakage cover is genuinely included — which is rare in standard home insurance but common in a dedicated all risks policy. Be careful: breakage caused by inadequate packing during transport may be excluded.

Are woodworm or humidity covered?

No. These are gradual deterioration and a lack of maintenance, excluded in principle from all insurance. Insurance covers sudden accidents, not progressive deterioration: prevention and conservation remain your responsibility.

Does every object in the collection need to be appraised?

Above a per-item value threshold set in the policy, yes. Below it, a documented inventory — photos, invoices, dimensions, hallmarks, provenance — is generally enough to support the value used.

Is a restored piece compensated at its original value?

Not always. A restoration, even a perfect one, can leave residual depreciation. A good policy compensates this loss of value on top of the cost of the work; check that this clause appears in the policy.

Are my objects covered during a house move or a loan?

With nail-to-nail cover, yes: the object remains covered continuously, including during transport, house moves, loans or a stay with a conservator. A home insurance policy, by contrast, generally stops at the home.

Have your collection's value agreed up front.