Cimaise
Shipping

ATA carnet and fine art insurance: temporary export

·9 min read·The Cimaise team
Antique marine painting of merchant sailing ships in a harbour, evoking the international movement of goods

You are showing three paintings on a stand in Basel, lending a sculpture to a New York museum, taking a piece to a client in Geneva: in each case, your works cross a border for a while and then come home. The ATA carnet is the tool that makes that journey simple at customs. But a costly confusion keeps coming up: many galleries, artists and collectors believe that a valid carnet is enough to protect the work. It is not. The carnet is a customs document; it pays nothing if a painting falls, is stolen or burns abroad. Here is where the carnet stops and where your insurance begins.

The ATA carnet, a customs passport — not an insurance policy

The ATA carnet (from Admission Temporaire / Temporary Admission) is an international customs document that lets you take goods temporarily out of a country, present them abroad, then re-import them without paying import duties or VAT at each border. It rests on the ATA Convention and the Istanbul Convention, and now works across more than eighty countries and territories.

In France, the carnet is issued by the chambers of commerce and industry (the Paris Île-de-France chamber and the regional chambers), usually in digital form (e-ATA) through the online export-formalities platform. It is valid for twelve months, during which you can make repeated trips to several destinations with the same goods listed on a general list.

The benefit is twofold. First, you avoid tying up a large amount of cash: without a carnet, the host country's customs may require a security deposit covering the duties and taxes, refunded on return. For a work declared at €500,000 in a country applying 20% import VAT, that deposit can reach €100,000 (a purely illustrative example). Second, the carnet simplifies the crossing: a single document, recognised on both sides, instead of separate declarations at each post.

But the ATA carnet guarantees one thing and one thing only: that, if the works do not leave the host country within the deadline, the duties and taxes will indeed be paid. It is a guarantee for the benefit of customs, not a protection for the owner. The physical risk — breakage, theft, fire, water damage during transit and the exhibition — stays entirely outside its scope.

What the carnet actually covers (and what it leaves out)

Three operations are often confused and must be separated:

  • The customs crossing: this is the carnet's role (or, failing that, a temporary export declaration).
  • Permission to send the item out: certain cultural goods — above thresholds of age and value — also require an export licence issued by the Ministry of Culture, temporary or permanent. The carnet never removes this requirement.
  • Protection of the work: this is the role of insurance, and of nothing else.

In other words, you can hold a perfectly drawn-up carnet, a valid licence, and still be left with no indemnity if the work is damaged on the return flight. The carnet knows only the declared customs value and the question "has the item left the country, yes or no?". It ignores the state of conservation, the depreciation after a knock, the loss of one piece from a pair. That is precisely the ground of an all-risks policy on an agreed value, which indemnifies physical damage from door to door, on a value settled in advance.

ATA carnet and insurance: two complementary protections

The two devices do not replace one another: they sit on top of one another. The table below sums up who does what.

QuestionATA carnetFine art insurance
NatureInternational customs documentProperty insurance contract
What it handlesCustoms duties and VAT on temporary import/exportTheft, breakage, fire, water damage, loss
Who is protectedThe customs administrationThe owner of the work
Reference valueDeclared customs valueAgreed value (set in the contract)
TriggerFailure to re-export within the deadlinePhysical loss to the work
Duration12 months, multiple tripsTerm of the contract / the insured movement

The sound practice is to move the work under an ATA carnet and a nail-to-nail cover, which protects the work from the moment it comes off the wall until it is rehung, including international transit, handling and time on site. For a gallery running a circuit of international fairs, this combination is the norm; our solutions designed for art galleries start from exactly this logic of repeated trips abroad.

The value trap: customs value and agreed value

This is the most common mistake, and the most consequential. On the carnet, you enter a customs value: the one used to calculate duties and taxes if the work were not to return. The temptation is to understate it to reduce the exposure on paper. A poor move on two counts.

First, a clearly understated customs value can be challenged by the host country's customs and may delay, or even block, the crossing. Second, that value has no link with what your insurer will pay you: the indemnity follows the agreed value written into the insurance contract, not the figure on the carnet. Two documents, two logics.

The ideal is to align the two on a serious appraisal basis: a work valued at its fair market value, insured on an agreed value for that amount, and declared to customs in a consistent way. A large gap between the two is a sign of fragility — either you are underinsured in the event of a loss, or you expose yourself to a customs reassessment. The two figures must tell the same story.

A loss abroad: when the carnet's guarantee turns against you

Here is the scenario people overlook. A work leaves under an ATA carnet for a fair abroad. During the event, it is stolen, or destroyed by fire. Two consequences fire off at once.

The first is an insurance matter: if you have a nail-to-nail cover on an agreed value, your insurer indemnifies the owner for the agreed amount. That is the expected protection, and it works.

The second is a customs matter, and it takes people by surprise. Because the work can no longer be re-exported, the carnet cannot be "discharged" (cleared) for that piece. The host country's customs then claim the import duties and VAT on the declared value, and the national guaranteeing association, which stood surety, settles those sums and then turns to the carnet holder for reimbursement. The result: on top of losing the work, you may have to bear a customs debt abroad.

A well-built file anticipates this double effect. The point is to check, with your broker, how the policy treats customs duties and taxes arising from a loss occurring under a carnet, and to keep flawless supporting documents (police report, condition record, photographs): they serve both the indemnity and the customs settlement. The same applies when a work is sold on site: the carnet only allows a temporary stay, so the sale must be regularised through a definitive import and payment of the taxes in the buyer's country.

Preparing a fair or exhibition departure: the method

For an international movement of works, the useful sequence is as follows:

  1. List the works precisely (title, artist, dimensions, value): this list serves both the carnet's general list and the insured inventory. A condition report at departure documents the exact state before the journey.
  2. Check the permissions: is an export licence from the Ministry of Culture required for any of the items? This is handled upstream, not the night before departure.
  3. Order the ATA carnet from the chamber of commerce, with consistent customs values and suitable geographical cover (countries visited and transit countries).
  4. Take out or extend the nail-to-nail cover for the period of the movement, on an agreed value, including the exhibition on site and the handling.
  5. Align the values: check that the customs value and the agreed value are consistent, and that the limits per work and per event match the value actually being moved.
  6. On return, discharge the carnet within the deadline and keep every customs endorsement.

This preparation largely overlaps with that of an international art shipment with customs clearance and of taking part in a fair or trade show. A specialist broker coordinates both sides — customs and insurance — so that no grey area is left between them. You can request a quote for a specific movement or for a programme of fairs across the year.

FAQ

Does the ATA carnet insure my works during transit?

No. The ATA carnet is a customs document: it suspends import duties and VAT during a temporary stay abroad. It covers neither theft, nor breakage, nor fire. Protecting the work is the job of a property insurance contract, ideally on a nail-to-nail, agreed-value basis.

How long is an ATA carnet valid?

An ATA carnet is valid for twelve months from the date of issue. During that period, the same works listed on the general list can make several trips to several countries within the ATA network, without redoing the formalities each time.

Who issues the ATA carnet in France?

The chambers of commerce and industry — in practice the Paris Île-de-France chamber and the regional chambers — issue it, usually in digital form (e-ATA). The chamber stands surety to customs for the duties and taxes that would become payable if the goods were not re-exported.

What value should I declare on the carnet?

The customs value, that is the market value used to calculate duties and taxes. It must be realistic: an understatement can be challenged by customs. It is independent of the agreed value in the insurance contract, but the two should remain consistent.

What happens if a work is stolen or destroyed abroad under a carnet?

Your insurance indemnifies the owner on the agreed value. But because the work can no longer be re-exported, the host country's customs claim duties and taxes on the declared value, and the surety may turn to the carnet holder. You should check with your broker how these post-loss customs costs are handled.

Does the ATA carnet remove the need for a cultural-goods export licence?

No. These are two separate formalities. Above certain thresholds of age and value, a cultural good requires an export licence issued by the Ministry of Culture, in addition to the ATA carnet or the customs declaration. The carnet never replaces that authorisation.

Have your collection's value agreed up front.