
A painting that stays in Paris never passes through a customs post. The same painting lent to a biennale abroad, sold to a buyer in New York or shown on a stand in Basel crosses borders, changes tax regime and passes through hands you do not choose. To the physical risk of transit is then added an administrative risk: a work held up at customs, wrongly declared or seized sometimes costs more than a damaged crate. Here is what really protects a work travelling beyond France's borders.
What a border adds to the risk
Domestic transport plays out over a few hours and a handful of parties. International transport lengthens the chain: collection, bonded storage, an air or sea leg, transit through a third country, customs clearance on arrival, final delivery. At every transfer point, one more pair of hands, one more warehouse, one more form.
Three new risks appear that do not exist on a domestic journey:
- Customs risk. An inconsistent declaration, a missing document or an incorrectly stated value can immobilise the work, or even lead to it being held while checks are carried out. The time lost is measured in weeks, not hours.
- Territorial risk. Your policy is not necessarily meant to cover every country in the world. Some destinations are excluded outright (embargoes, international sanctions), others require a specific extension.
- Legal risk. Property rights, restitution rules and limitation periods vary from one country to another. A work with a complex history is more exposed when it travels.
The basic rule does not change — cover must follow the work without interruption — but it becomes more demanding: the cover must be worldwide and continuous, and the customs formalities must be beyond reproach.
The ATA carnet: a customs passport, not insurance
The ATA carnet (Admission Temporaire / *Temporary Admission*) is the key document for temporary international transport. It replaces the many usual customs declarations and allows a work to circulate abroad with duties and taxes suspended, provided it is re-exported in its original condition before the expiry date. It is particularly well suited to art: a piece lent to an exhibition or shown at a fair is not meant to enter the host country's market — it has to leave again.
In France, the ATA carnet is issued by the chambers of commerce and industry (CCI) and relies on an international guarantee chain; it is valid for one year. Its cost remains modest: a fraction of a percent of the declared value, by way of example.
One point is essential, and often misunderstood: the ATA carnet is not insurance. It is a customs guarantee — it protects the authorities against non-payment of duties if the work does not leave again. It does not compensate you for breakage, theft or water damage occurring en route. The two are complementary and both indispensable: the carnet deals with customs, the insurance deals with the loss. The foundation of this cover remains our all-risks agreed-value policy, with nail-to-nail cover worldwide.
One final subtlety: if the work is sold during its stay abroad, it becomes a definitive import. The ATA carnet then ceases to apply, and the country's duties and VAT become payable.
What an international policy covers — and what it excludes
Nail-to-nail cover can extend worldwide, provided the policy says so. It then covers the work continuously — from being taken down to being rehung — including during transit, bonded storage and the stay at destination: accidental physical damage, theft, disappearance, fire, water damage. On an agreed-value basis, compensation is based on the value stated in the policy, with no renegotiation after the event, as we explain in our article on transit insurance and nail-to-nail cover.
Exclusions on international journeys deserve careful reading: some simply do not arise on a domestic journey.
| Cause | Generally | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Impact, fall, breakage in transit | Covered | Physical contingency, the core of the cover |
| Theft, disappearance abroad | Covered | Included in worldwide nail-to-nail cover |
| War, riot, strike (SRCC) | Excluded unless extended | Political risk, to be bought back for sensitive routes |
| Seizure, confiscation, customs detention | Excluded | Decision of a public authority |
| Embargo, international sanctions | Excluded | Destination outside the insurable scope |
| Defective or inadequate packing | Excluded | Preparation failure attributable to the shipper |
| Delay and indirect financial loss | Excluded | Non-physical loss, outside property cover |
For a sea shipment, a mechanism specific to maritime law may apply: general average. If the master sacrifices cargo or incurs costs to save the voyage (jettisoning cargo, towage), the owners of the saved goods contribute in proportion to their value. A good transit insurance policy pays this contribution — provided it is included.
The carrier's liability is capped by law
Many people wrongly believe that "the carrier is liable". It is — but within limits set by international conventions that cap compensation by weight, not by the value of the object. For a work of art, the gap is staggering.
| Mode of transport | Convention | Legal limit (indicative) |
|---|---|---|
| Air | Montreal Convention | ~22 SDR per kilo |
| International road | CMR Convention | 8.33 SDR per kilo |
| Sea | Hague-Visby Rules | 2 SDR/kg or 666.67 SDR per package |
An example speaks for itself. A 12-kilo painting insured for €300,000 travels by air. In the event of a loss, the Montreal Convention limit comes to a few hundred euros — out of all proportion to the real value. Relying on the carrier's liability means accepting derisory compensation in advance. Only insurance at declared value, taken out by the owner, covers the work for what it is really worth. That is precisely the approach we apply to the professionals who move works around, on our page for art sales, registrars and art transport.
Declared value, currency and territorial scope: the three checks
Before a work leaves the country, three points determine how solid your cover really is.
- Territorial scope. Check in black and white that the destination country — and the transit countries — fall within the geographical scope of the policy. "France and European Union" cover does not protect a loan to Tokyo or a sale in New York without an endorsement.
- Declared value and currency. The insured value must be consistent with the customs value declared on the carnet. A marked discrepancy between the two draws the attention of customs and, where applicable, weakens the claim. Also specify the currency of compensation, especially for a work valued in dollars or pounds.
- A condition report at every stage. A photographic *condition report* at departure, at every border and on arrival establishes exactly when damage occurred. It is the cornerstone of any international loss assessment, where the chain of responsibility is long.
These checks echo those we describe for a work located outside France in our article on insuring a work abroad or in a second home: the principle is the same — cover must be territorially explicit.
The steps for a successful international shipment
A cross-border shipment is prepared well in advance, not the day before departure. The sequence, in order:
- Choose a specialist shipper. Fine art freight is not ordinary freight: climate-controlled crates, bespoke bracing, trained technicians, a network of agents abroad. It is the first line of defence against loss — and against the exclusion for defective packing.
- Open the right customs procedure. An ATA carnet for a round trip (loan, fair, exhibition), or definitive clearance in the case of a sale. A customs broker secures the formalities and the timelines.
- Draw up the condition report. Detailed photographs and a precise description before departure, to be kept as a reference.
- Confirm the scope of cover. Countries covered, war and strike (SRCC) extensions for sensitive routes, general average included for sea freight.
- Update the agreed value. A value entered in the policy five years ago no longer reflects the market — an endorsement updates it before departure.
- On arrival, act quickly. If damage is visible: move nothing, take photographs, give the carrier written notice of reservations within the time limits, then report the claim to your broker.
A specialist broker orchestrates this chain — shipper, customs, insurer — and defends your file if an incident occurs thousands of kilometres away. That is often where the difference between full compensation and partial payment is decided.
FAQ
Does the ATA carnet insure my work during transport?
No. The ATA carnet is a customs document that suspends duties and taxes during a temporary stay abroad. It covers neither breakage, nor theft, nor damage. Separate transit insurance, ideally nail-to-nail, remains essential.
Does my nail-to-nail policy cover a shipment outside France?
Only if its territorial scope provides for it. Check that the destination country and the transit countries are included; otherwise, an endorsement is needed. Some destinations under sanctions remain uninsurable.
Is the carrier's liability enough if the work is damaged abroad?
No. International conventions (Montreal, CMR, Hague-Visby) cap compensation by weight, not by value. For a work of art, that amounts to a few hundred euros at best — bearing no relation to its real value.
Should war and riot risks be insured for international transport?
For sensitive routes or unstable areas, yes. These risks (war, riots, strikes, known as SRCC) are generally excluded from the standard policy and can be bought back through an extension, often recommended on long air and sea legs.
What happens if the work is sold during its stay abroad?
It becomes a definitive import: the ATA carnet ceases to apply and the country's duties and VAT become payable. The insurance must then reflect the new owner and the new place where the work is kept.
Who handles the customs formalities for a work of art?
A customs broker or the specialist fine art shipper, who prepares the ATA carnet and the declarations. Your broker coordinates the whole process so that the insurance cover and the customs procedure are consistent from start to finish.