
Water damage has left a tide mark on a gouache, a shipper has cracked an antique frame, a burglary has carried off a canvas: you report the loss, the loss adjuster appointed by the insurer visits, and the figure that comes back seems far below what the market would pay. This stand-off is common, and it is not a dead end. The insurance policy sets out precisely what to do when you dispute the amount offered — but you still need to know your levers and pull them in the right order, before you have signed anything.
Where the disagreement comes from, even when everything seems in order
A settlement rests on two separate assessments, and the dispute almost always arises over one or the other. The first concerns the value of the work: if your policy uses market value (the market value on the day of the loss), the insurer's appraiser may put it far lower than what you would have obtained from a dealer or at auction. The second concerns the extent of the damage: for a work that is damaged but not destroyed, everything turns on the cost of restoration and, above all, on the residual depreciation — the loss in value that remains once the work has been restored.
This is often where positions harden. The policyholder experiences the stain or the tear as a permanent wound; the insurer's appraiser tends to minimise the loss in value once the work has been done. The gap widens further when documentation is lacking: with no invoice, no certificate and no prior appraisal, each side defends an estimate that nothing can settle. Before opening your challenge, reread the terms of your claim notification and gather everything that proves the value and the previous condition of the item.
Agreed value: the best safeguard against a dispute
The most effective way to defuse a disagreement happens upstream, at inception. Under an all risks policy on an agreed value basis, the compensation value of each work is fixed by mutual agreement when the policy is taken out, on the basis of an appraisal or supporting evidence. In the event of a total loss, the insurer pays that amount without being able to reopen the underlying value: the debate over "what this canvas is really worth" simply no longer arises.
The difference with market value is fundamental; we explain it in our comparison of agreed value versus market value. Remember the essential point: agreed value does not remove every dispute — partial damage can still lead to debate over depreciation — but it eliminates the most common source of conflict. An up-to-date inventory and recent appraisals play the same role: the better documented your collection, the less room the insurer's appraiser has to push the figure down.
First reflex: the counter-appraisal
If you consider an offer insufficient, do not sign the settlement agreement. You have the right to appoint your own appraiser: this is known as a counter-appraisal, carried out by a "policyholder's appraiser" who defends your interests, as opposed to the appraiser appointed by the insurer.
This appraiser examines the work, reconstructs its value from market comparables, costs the restoration and the depreciation, then writes a reasoned report. Their fees are in principle at your expense — unless your policy includes legal protection cover that may pay them in whole or in part. For a valuable work, the investment is often more than repaid by the increase in compensation it secures. Choose an appraiser familiar with the relevant segment of the art market: valuing an Old Master painting, a contemporary photograph or a sculpture is not something to improvise.
The joint appraisal, step by step
Once your appraiser has been appointed, the procedure becomes a joint appraisal: the two appraisers — yours and the insurer's — compare their analyses, examine the damaged item together and seek common ground. In practice, it follows a fairly well-defined sequence:
- Appraisal meeting: the two appraisers inspect the work, compare their evidence (invoices, certificates, sales comparables) and discuss the points of disagreement.
- Negotiation: each defends their figures for the value, the cost of restoration and the depreciation.
- Written record: if an agreement is reached, it is recorded in writing and serves as the basis for the settlement. Many claims are resolved at this stage.
The joint appraisal has one great merit: it rebalances the balance of power. You are no longer alone facing a professional appointed by the party that pays; an appraiser on your side speaks the same technical language. In most cases, this simple dialogue between equals is enough to bring the positions closer together.
The third-party appraisal: when deadlock persists
If the two appraisers cannot agree, most policies provide for a third-party appraisal. A third, independent appraiser is appointed jointly by the first two; if they cannot agree on a name, the appointment may be made by the president of the court for the place where the loss occurred. Their role is to decide.
Two features deserve your attention. First, their opinion is binding on both parties: barring fraud or gross error, the third appraiser's report cannot be challenged on the merits. Second, their fees are shared equally between you and the insurer — each party also remaining liable for the fees of its own appraiser. The third-party appraisal is therefore a serious technical arbitration, not to be triggered lightly: it is used when the remaining gap justifies the cost and the risk of deferring to a third party.
Who pays the costs?
The "costs" item is often poorly anticipated. Here is the most common split (the exact terms depend on your policy):
| Cost item | Your expense | Insurer | Shared 50/50 |
|---|---|---|---|
| Insurer's appraiser | — | Yes | — |
| Your appraiser (counter-appraisal) | Yes* | — | — |
| Third appraiser (third-party appraisal) | — | — | Yes |
| Médiation de l'assurance (insurance ombudsman) | Free | Free | Free |
| Court-appointed expert | Advanced by the claimant, decided by the judge | — | — |
*Unless covered, in whole or in part, by legal protection insurance.
Anticipating these costs is part of good preparation: for a major work, the difference in compensation at stake generally far exceeds the cost of a policyholder's appraiser. As a purely illustrative example, engaging an appraiser to defend a disputed loss in value of several tens of thousands of euros remains highly worthwhile.
Insurance mediation and legal action
Not every deadlock can be resolved technically. When the disagreement is not about a figure but about how the policy applies — refusal of cover, interpretation of an exclusion, application of a deductible — the right tool in France is the Médiation de l'assurance, the French insurance ombudsman service. It is free, independent and confidential; you refer the matter to it after sending a written complaint to your insurer that has not received a satisfactory answer. The mediator issues an opinion, which the insurer follows in the vast majority of cases.
Legal action remains the last resort. You can ask the court for a court-ordered expert appraisal (often through summary proceedings), entrusted to an expert listed with the court of appeal. It is longer and more expensive, but sometimes necessary in the face of total deadlock or a dispute of principle. A word of caution: insurers operating in France are supervised by the ACPR (the French prudential supervisory authority) and intermediaries are registered with ORIAS (the French register of insurance intermediaries); where a clause is ambiguous, the benefit of the doubt goes to the policyholder. Do not hesitate to have your policy reviewed by a professional before starting proceedings.
The habits that make the difference
- Do not sign anything under pressure. A receipt in full and final settlement closes the file; as long as you have not signed, negotiation remains open.
- Do not restore or throw away the work before an agreement is reached: the appraiser must be able to see the real extent of the damage.
- Put everything in writing. Registered letters, dated photos, reports: the burden of proof rests largely on you.
- Document in advance. A solid inventory file and up-to-date appraisals are worth more than any after-the-event negotiation. They are also what allow you, at inception, to request a perfectly calibrated agreed value quote.
- Watch the deadlines. The policy sets deadlines for notification and response; meeting them preserves your rights.
A disagreement over a settlement is nothing unusual, and it is all the easier to handle if you have prepared the ground before the loss. To go further on what is at stake once the work has been repaired, see our article on depreciation after restoration.
FAQ
Can I refuse the settlement offered by my insurer?
Yes. As long as you have not signed the settlement agreement or a receipt in full and final settlement, you can dispute the amount and start a counter-appraisal. Refusing an offer does not cancel your cover; it opens the negotiation phase.
Who pays the appraiser I appoint to defend me?
In principle, the fees of your policyholder's appraiser are at your expense. Check your policy, however: legal protection cover may pay them in whole or in part. For a valuable work, this cost is often offset by the gain in compensation.
Is the third-party appraisal really binding on both parties?
Its result is binding on both parties. Barring fraud or gross error by the third appraiser, their valuation can no longer be challenged on the merits. Their fees are shared equally between you and the insurer.
When should I go to the Médiation de l'assurance rather than an appraiser?
Mediation is suited to disputes about how the policy applies: refusal of cover, interpretation of an exclusion or a deductible. It is free and is available after a written complaint that has not received a satisfactory answer. For a simple disagreement over an amount, the appraisal route is more direct.
Does agreed value prevent any disagreement?
It removes the most frequent dispute, the one over the underlying value: in the event of a total loss, the insurer pays the agreed amount. Partial damage can nevertheless still lead to debate over the cost of restoration and the residual depreciation.
How long does a settlement take when it is disputed?
It varies widely depending on the complexity and the degree of disagreement. A counter-appraisal followed by a joint appraisal is often settled within a few weeks to a few months; a third-party appraisal or legal proceedings lengthen the timeline considerably.