
A work that tips over as it is taken down, water damage discovered early in the morning, a display case forced open: a loss always strikes at the worst moment. What happens next depends not only on your policy, but on what you do in the first hours — notifying within the deadline, reporting to the police, preserving the evidence. Here is the procedure to follow, loss by loss, so that your compensation does not get lost along the way.
The first hours: the steps that protect your compensation
Your first reflex should not be to call the insurer, but to avoid making things worse. A fallen canvas, a split frame, paper cockled by water: it is tempting to clean, glue back or dry. Touch nothing. Any intervention before the loss adjuster's visit may be treated as additional damage — and complicate the assessment of the real loss.
Three steps, in this order:
- Secure. Move the work out of immediate danger (a water leak, a heat source, unprotected access after a break-in) without handling it more than necessary. Wear gloves for any unavoidable move.
- Document. Photograph the work and its surroundings from several angles, before moving anything. Date the photos. Gather what you already have: certificate, purchase invoice, appraisal report, provenance.
- Notify. Inform your insurer or broker within the contractual deadline. It is this deadline, often overlooked, that sinks claims that are otherwise legitimate.
The duty to take protective measures also works the other way: you must limit any worsening of the damage. Mopping up water on the floor around a painting, cutting off the humidity, moving a heat source away are common sense and expected of you. The line is simple: you protect the surroundings, you do not restore the work.
Each type of loss has its own deadline
In France, the Code des assurances (French Insurance Code) sets a minimum deadline for reporting a loss: five working days as a general rule, reduced to two working days in the case of theft. Your policy may extend these deadlines, never shorten them. In practice, do not rely on the margin: notify quickly, and complete the file afterwards.
| Type of loss | Notification deadline | First step |
|---|---|---|
| Theft, burglary | 2 working days | Report to the police or gendarmerie |
| Water damage, fire | 5 working days | Photos + protective measures, without restoration |
| Breakage in transit | 5 working days | Written reservations to the carrier on delivery |
| Damage during an exhibition | 5 working days | Report signed with the borrower, condition compared with the incoming condition report |
What all these situations have in common: the burden of proof lies with you. An all risks policy on an agreed value basis considerably lightens this burden, since the value of the work is already fixed in the policy — but the fact of the loss itself still has to be established.
Theft: why the police report is decisive
In the event of theft, reporting to the police is not a formality: it is the document that triggers the cover. Go to the police station or gendarmerie with your photos and documentation. The receipt for your report, with its precise description of the work, will be required by the insurer.
Then report the stolen work to the specialist databases. In France, the Office central de lutte contre le trafic des biens culturels (OCBC, the French police unit dedicated to cultural property trafficking) feeds the TREIMA database; internationally, the Art Loss Register lists missing works. A registered work becomes much harder to resell, and registration is sometimes a condition of cover. Your broker can coordinate these reports.
The insurer may ask for a waiting period before paying out on a theft: policies often provide for a period — typically a few weeks to a few months — during which the work may resurface. This is not a delaying tactic, but time allowed for the search. Once this period has passed, the compensation is paid and the insurer is subrogated to your rights over the work.
Breakage, fire, water damage: physical loss
Here, the work is still there, but damaged. The question is no longer "where is it?" but "what is it still worth?". Two notions will shape the compensation: the cost of restoration and depreciation.
If the damage occurs during transit, make precise written reservations to the carrier at the time of delivery. Vague reservations ("package damaged") are not enough: describe the nature of the damage. These reservations preserve the insurer's right of recourse against the carrier, and therefore, indirectly, your claim. The logic of an agreed value policy versus market value comes into its own here: the basis of compensation is not negotiated after the event.
In a fire or water damage, smoke, soot and humidity often do more harm than the fire or water themselves. Paper, gouache and photographs are particularly vulnerable. Ventilate, move the works away from residual humidity, but leave the diagnosis to the appointed conservator.
From notification to compensation: the role of the appraisal
Once the loss has been reported, the insurer appoints a loss adjuster. Their task: establish the fact of the damage, cost the restoration if it is possible, and assess the residual loss of value. You can, for your part, bring in your own appraiser: this is the principle of the joint appraisal, and it is often decisive for a valuable work.
The basis of compensation depends on the nature of your policy. This is the difference with the heaviest consequences.
| Situation | Home insurance (market value) | Specialist policy (agreed value) |
|---|---|---|
| Total loss | Market value estimated after the event | Value stated in the policy, paid without renegotiation |
| Restoration | Capped cover | Actual cost of restoration |
| Depreciation after restoration | Rarely compensated | Loss of artistic value assessed and compensated |
| Transit and loans | Often excluded | Covered nail-to-nail |
To understand how the value stated in the policy is established in advance — and why it makes compensation predictable — the details are in our guide to having a work of art appraised for insurance. This step, taken at inception, is what distinguishes a claim settled in a few weeks from a negotiation that drags on.
Deductible, exclusions and depreciation: what reduces the payout
Three elements can reduce — sometimes considerably — the final cheque.
The deductible. This is the share that remains at your expense. On a specialist policy it is generally moderate, but it exists. Check whether it applies per loss or per work. Exclusions. Inherent vice (an intrinsic weakness of the material), wear and tear, lack of maintenance, gradual deterioration: these are not accidental losses, and they are excluded. Craquelure due to natural ageing is not a claim; a fall that causes a tear is. The distinction is often made in the appraisal report. Depreciation. A restored work, even perfectly restored, may be worth less than before: this is the loss of artistic value. A good policy compensates for it on top of the cost of restoration; many general policies ignore it. On a sought-after piece, this gap weighs heavily.One last useful habit: keep a written record of all your exchanges with the insurer and, if the compensation offered seems unfair to you, know that an amicable appeal is available before any litigation. A broker defends your claim at this stage. If you are not yet covered, or poorly covered, it is better to know before a loss: now is the right time to request an agreed value insurance quote.
FAQ
Within what deadline must I report a loss affecting a work of art?
In France, the minimum legal deadline is five working days, reduced to two working days in the case of theft. Your policy may provide for longer deadlines, never shorter ones. In practice, notify as soon as possible and complete the file afterwards.
Do I have to report to the police before informing my insurer?
In the case of theft, yes: the police report is the document that triggers the cover, and the receipt will be required. You can inform your broker at the same time, but the police report remains essential.
Can I have the work restored straight away?
No, not before the loss adjuster's visit. Restoration started too early may prevent an accurate assessment of the damage and the loss of value. Secure and document, but leave the diagnosis to the appointed conservator.
What happens if the stolen work is found after compensation?
Once compensated, you transfer your rights over the work to the insurer, which is subrogated. If it resurfaces, it belongs in principle to the insurer — but many policies provide a buy-back option allowing you to recover it by repaying the compensation.
Does a restored work lose value, and is that covered?
Often, yes: even a successful restoration leaves a mark on its market value — this is the loss of artistic value. A specialist policy compensates for it on top of the cost of restoration; check this point, as many general policies do not cover it.