Cimaise
Cover & extension

Depreciation cover: loss of value after a claim, indemnified

A work that is damaged and then restored does not always regain its full value on the market. Depreciation cover indemnifies this residual loss of value — the discount that remains even after a flawless restoration.

Still Life with Apples and a Pot of Primroses — Paul Cézanne
Paul Cézanne, Still Life with Apples and a Pot of Primroses (c. 1890). The Met, public domain.
The loss of value, not just the repairBeyond the cost of restoration, the drop in market value caused by the incident is taken into account.
Even after a perfect restorationThe market values a damaged work less: it is this discount that is covered.
Assessed by appraisalDepreciation is established by an appraiser, on the basis of the agreed value in the policy.

Restoration alone does not restore a work's value

A torn canvas that has been relined, a vase glued back together, a drawing that has been cleaned: restoration makes the work presentable, sometimes undetectable to the eye. But the art market remembers the accident. A piece that has been damaged almost always sells for less than one that has remained intact, even after exemplary restoration.

That difference — depreciation — is not covered by simply reimbursing the restoration costs. It is a real financial loss, which only dedicated cover pays for.

What is covered
  • The loss of value remaining after restoration
  • On top of restoration costs
  • Established by appraisal, against the agreed value
  • For repairable damage
What is not
  • Normal wear and ageing
  • A drop in market value without an insured loss
  • Cosmetic work unrelated to a loss

How depreciation is indemnified

After the loss and the restoration, an appraiser assesses the value of the work. Depreciation is the gap between the agreed value before the incident and the market value after restoration. That gap is what is indemnified, on top of the restoration costs.

The mechanism only makes sense under an agreed value policy, where the reference value is fixed in advance. To understand the principle, see our article on agreed value versus market value and our core policy.

Covered bowl and stand, Vincennes porcelain
Vincennes manufactory, covered bowl and stand (c. 1752–53). The Met.
“Restoration makes the work presentable; the market remembers the accident.”
Does this cover fit your situation?
A broker tailors your policy and gets back to you within 48 hours.
Get a quote

For which works does it matter most?

Depreciation weighs most heavily on works whose value lies in their physical integrity: Old Master paintings, collectible pieces, rare objects. An accident, even minor and well repaired, can lead to a significant discount.

It is an extension closely followed by collectors, galleries and institutions, whose pieces are meant to circulate and, one day, to be sold or passed on.

An example

A work with an agreed value of €50,000 is damaged and then perfectly restored. On the market, it is now worth only €38,000 because of the incident. Depreciation cover indemnifies the €12,000 loss of value, on top of the restoration costs.

Frequently asked questions

How is depreciation measured?
By appraisal, comparing the agreed value of the work before the loss with its market value after restoration. The difference is the depreciation indemnified.
Is it standard cover?
It is an extension to be added to the policy. It is common on collections insured at agreed value, but should be requested explicitly.
Is restoration covered too?
Yes: restoration costs fall under the core all-risks cover. Depreciation comes on top, for the loss of value that remains afterwards.
What if the work cannot be repaired?
In the event of a total loss, the agreed value is paid in full — depreciation only comes into play for repairable damage.
Restored, but worth less? The difference is covered.