
Winning a commission under France's "1% artistique" scheme means being handed a giant studio and an unfamiliar responsibility. For months, a valuable work takes shape in your studio, travels, then settles permanently into a public space. Between signing the contract and the commissioning body formally accepting the piece, this unique work crosses a grey zone: no longer a project, not yet public property, and almost always still the artist's to keep insured. Understanding where the risk sits, and exactly when it shifts, is what stops a site accident or a transport mishap from turning a prestigious commission into a financial disaster.
The 1% artistique: a commission, not a purchase
The "1% artistique" — formally the obligation to allocate part of a public building's budget to art — requires a public project owner (the State, a local authority, a public body) to devote roughly 1% of the cost of a new building to commissioning or acquiring work by a living artist, designed specifically for that building. Governed by the French public procurement code, the scheme has placed thousands of sculptures, murals, stained-glass works and installations in public spaces since the 1950s.
For the artist, the legal nuance matters enormously: you are not selling a finished work, you become the holder of a public contract covering the design, making, delivery and installation of a new piece. The 1% budget pays for all of these — transport and installation included — but not for mishaps. Example, for illustration: for a secondary school built for 5 million euros, the 1% envelope is around 50,000 euros; if the work is damaged the day before its unveiling and no insurance responds, it is the artist who absorbs the blow.
This contract logic, rather than a simple sale, explains why insurance arises differently from a painting sold through a gallery. It belongs to the cover designed for artists and their output, a world many creators discover with their first institutional commission.
When the risk shifts: from studio to acceptance
The thread running through any public commission is the transfer of risk. Until the work has been formally accepted by the project owner, it stays, in the vast majority of contracts, the artist's responsibility. Acceptance is the act by which the authority recognises the work as compliant and takes it on: that is the moment ownership and the burden of risk pass to the commissioning body.
Before that step, the work passes through several phases, each with its own risk profile:
- Making in the studio: the piece is built, sometimes over many months, and already concentrates high value. Fire, water damage and studio theft are the classic risks.
- Transport to the site: the most accident-prone phase, especially for monumental or fragile pieces that often travel as abnormal loads.
- Installation and lifting: craning, anchoring, working at height — one wrong move can destroy months of work.
- Between installation and acceptance: the work is in place but not yet accepted; it is exposed to the public, and to vandalism, while still resting on the artist.
| Phase | Who bears the risk | Useful cover |
|---|---|---|
| Design, making in the studio | The artist (contract holder) | All-risks studio / work in progress |
| Transport to the site | The artist (unless agreed otherwise) | Nail-to-nail transit cover |
| Installation, lifting, anchoring | The artist and/or the installer | Erection-and-testing, installer liability |
| Between installation and acceptance | The artist | Damage and vandalism on site |
| After acceptance | The public project owner | The authority's own estate |
This shift at acceptance mirrors the logic of all-risks cover on an agreed value, nail to nail: insuring the work continuously, from one point to the next, with no gap between the studio, the road and the plinth.
What the artist must actually insure
A public commission contract almost always contains an "Insurance" article requiring the holder to prove cover. Two strands stand apart, and must not be confused.
The first is professional liability. It covers damage the artist or the works might cause to third parties or to the building: a faulty anchoring, a falling element, an injured passer-by. This is the cover most often demanded explicitly by the authority, because it protects the authority itself.
The second, often forgotten, is insurance of the work itself — its value, not that of third parties. If the piece burns in the studio or breaks during lifting before acceptance, no liability policy pays for it: you need damage cover on the work, from its creation through to its acceptance. That is what protects the artist's labour and finances.
A few points of vigilance come up again and again:
- The value to insure is not merely the 1% envelope: an irreplaceable monumental work can cost far more to rebuild than the strictly artistic share of the contract.
- Subcontractors (foundry, installer, specialist carrier) must carry their own insurance; check who answers for what if something breaks.
- The chain must have no gap: many losses occur at the join between two providers, for instance when the work leaves the foundry's workshop for the lorry.
Having these clauses read by a broker familiar with how artists work avoids discovering, on the day of a loss, that the policy only covered liability and not the work.
Monumental, in situ, permanent: the risks specific to public commissions
A public commission is not an easel painting. Three features make it an insurance object in its own right.
First, scale. Many 1% works are monumental sculptures, outdoor installations or pieces integrated into the fabric of the building. Their transport and installation call for heavy logistics, with cranes and convoys. The mechanisms and precautions are the same as for any monumental work moved and installed by lifting: this is where the costliest losses cluster.
Second, permanent exposure. A 1% work lives outdoors or in a hall open to the public, exposed to weather, pollution, graffiti and sometimes vandalism. Before acceptance, such damage remains the artist's risk; afterwards, it becomes a conservation concern for the authority, which has not always planned a maintenance budget.
Third, irreplaceability. A piece conceived for a specific place cannot be "re-bought" on the market. If it is destroyed, the real question is the cost of rebuilding — where that is even possible — and the loss of the original. This points towards an agreed value set at signing rather than an after-the-event estimate, always a source of dispute.
After acceptance: who takes over
Once the work is accepted, responsibility leaves the artist. The piece enters the public owner's estate and, as such, its insurance logic — which differs greatly from a private individual's.
The State and many local authorities partly self-insure: they carry certain risks on their estate themselves rather than buying a dedicated policy for every work. Others fold 1% works into a "collections" or "movable heritage" contract. Either way, the artist no longer bears the risk, but has every interest in acceptance being clearly dated and documented: that is what marks the end of their exposure.
For an institution managing a body of works — including 1% pieces inherited from decades of building — the question joins that of museum and institution insurance: inventory, up-to-date values, preventive conservation. For the artist, the reflex is simpler: never let the period before acceptance run without cover.
The reflexes before signing the contract
A few checks, made early, head off most nasty surprises:
- Read the "Insurance" article of the contract: does it clearly separate liability from cover on the work? What exactly does it require, and until when?
- Map the transfer of risk: when is acceptance scheduled, and who carries the work until then?
- Insure the work, not just third parties: take out damage cover on the piece while it is made, moved and installed.
- Check subcontractors' insurance: foundry, carrier, installer — and hunt for gaps between providers.
- Set a realistic agreed value, reflecting the rebuild cost, not just the artistic share of the 1%.
- Document acceptance: date, report, condition of the work — this is the finish line of your responsibility.
A public commission is often a turning point in an artist's career. Securing the insurance side protects the work, the deadline and your finances at once. If you are preparing a bid for a 1% artistique contract, you can request a quote suited to a public commission and have the insurance clauses reviewed by a specialist broker before you commit.
FAQ
Who must insure the work during a 1% artistique commission?
In most contracts the artist, as holder, stays responsible for the work until the project owner accepts it. So it falls to the artist to insure the piece while it is made, transported and installed. After acceptance, the burden passes to the commissioning authority.
Is professional liability enough for a public commission?
No. Professional liability covers damage caused to third parties or to the building, but not the work itself. If the piece is destroyed in the studio or during lifting, only damage cover on the work pays the artist. The two strands are complementary.
What exactly does the 1% envelope pay for?
It funds the design, making, delivery and installation of the work, along with procedure costs. It does not cover mishaps: a loss during the works is not met by this envelope, which is why dedicated insurance matters.
When does my responsibility as an artist end?
At the project owner's acceptance of the work, a formal act that transfers ownership and risk to the authority. Hence the value of a clearly dated, documented acceptance: it marks the end of your exposure and the start of the commissioning body's.
How do I set the value to insure for a monumental work?
For a unique piece designed for a place, you reason in terms of rebuild cost and the value of the original, not just the artistic share of the contract. An agreed value, settled at inception and written into the policy, avoids valuation disputes after a loss.
Must subcontractors be insured separately?
Yes. Foundry, specialist carrier and installer must hold their own cover. Check who answers for what, because many losses happen at the join between two providers, for example as the work leaves the foundry's workshop.