Cimaise
Coverage

Insuring your artworks during renovation work

·8 min read·The Cimaise team
Gallery interior with walls hung with old canvases, illustrating a collection to protect during building work

A renovation project turns your home into a risk zone: abrasive dust, hammer-drill vibrations, workers coming and going, badly secured dust sheets, a leak on a reopened pipe. For an old canvas, a sculpture or a series of photographic prints, these few weeks concentrate more danger than a whole year of quiet display. And one common mistake is costly: believing that the insurance for your building work also protects your collection. It almost never does. Here is how to properly safeguard your artworks before, during and after the work.

Why building work is one of the worst times for a collection

Renovation combines risks that, the rest of the time, remain scattered. Handling first: works are taken down, moved and stacked in a "buffer" room that is rarely suitable. Then knocks, when scaffolding, a sheet of plasterboard or a heavy piece of furniture brushes against an artwork left on the wall. Finally the environment: sanding dust gets in everywhere, the moisture from fresh screed or levelling compound pushes up humidity, and temperature swings multiply when doors and windows stay open.

On top of this comes a human risk. For weeks, outsiders move around your home, sometimes when you are not there, often with the front door left open. Opportunistic theft and accidental damage rise accordingly. Water damage remains the most ordinary cause of loss on a building site: a joint re-soldered, a tap turned back on too soon, and the water always finds the lowest point — often the wall where your finest painting was hanging.

What your building works insurance does not cover

This is the point most owners discover too late. Insurance linked to building work protects the works and the structure, not your valuable personal property.

Dommages-ouvrage insurance (France's compulsory building defects insurance), taken out by the project owner, pre-finances the repair of defects falling under the ten-year builder's warranty (those that compromise the soundness or use of the building). It does not compensate for a fallen painting or a shattered statue. Contractors' all risks (CAR) insurance (*tous risques chantier*, TRC) covers physical damage occurring during construction: poor workmanship, fire, theft of materials, bad weather. Its subject remains the works in progress and site equipment, not your private collection. As for the tradespeople's liability insurance, it only applies if their fault is proven — a long process, with an uncertain outcome, and capped.
PolicyWho takes it outWhat it coversYour artworks?
Dommages-ouvrage (building defects)Project ownerTen-year structural defectsNo
Contractors' all risks (TRC)Project owner / contractorWorks in progress, materialsNo
Tradesperson's liabilityBuilding contractorDamage caused by proven faultRarely, and capped
Home insuranceYouContents, with a "valuables" limitPartly, often insufficient
All-risks agreed value fine art policyYouThe artwork, nail-to-nailYes

Home insurance deserves a nuance. It often includes your possessions, but applies a "valuables" limit that is quickly exceeded (frequently a few tens of thousands of euros for the whole home), pays out at market value on the day of the loss and excludes many causes specific to building work. For a valuable piece, the net has too many holes. Only an all-risks agreed value policy really meets the need: it sets the compensated value in advance and follows the artwork everywhere, including into the room where it has been put away for safety.

Tell your art insurer before the first hammer blow

The rule to remember: building work changes the risk the insurer agreed to cover, so it must be declared. In home insurance as in specialist insurance, keeping quiet about a major project can reduce, or even void, compensation in the event of a loss.

Notify your broker or art insurer as soon as the works schedule is set, ideally two to three weeks before work begins. Specify the nature of the work (structural, electrical, plumbing, decorating), its duration, the rooms concerned and, above all, where the artworks will be moved to. If you entrust part of the collection to a conservation provider or a storage facility, say so: the cover must then include transport and the storage location, a point detailed in our article on insuring artworks in storage.

A good specialist policy works on a nail-to-nail basis: it protects the artwork continuously, from the moment it is taken down until it is reinstalled, including transport and temporary storage. That is exactly the situation of a renovation. To understand the extent of this cover, see our explanation of nail-to-nail cover.

Practical measures to protect your artworks

Insurance compensates; prevention avoids the loss. The two go hand in hand, and an insurer values serious measures — they sometimes weigh on the premium and always on the outcome of a dispute.

  • Inventory and photograph each piece before the work: overall and detail shots, backs, signatures, numbers. A dated record makes any claim easier and establishes the artwork's prior condition.
  • Take down and put away everything that can be moved in a locked room, outside the work zone, raised off the floor to guard against water damage.
  • Never leave an artwork on the wall "because it is heavy": it is often the one most exposed to knocks and splashes.
  • Protect what cannot be moved (fresco, fixed work, large format) with a box enclosure, a breathable sheet and clear signage for the workers.
  • Control humidity and dust: avoid storing near fresh screed or plaster, seal off the refuge room, monitor temperature and humidity.
  • Manage access: who holds the keys, at what times, with what supervision in your absence. Put it in writing.

To go further on these measures, our guide to risk prevention and caring for a collection details the security and preventive conservation side.

Take down, move or store: making the right call

Three options are open to you depending on the scale of the work, and each calls for suitable cover.

ScenarioWhen to choose itInsurance point to watch
Leave in place, protectedLight work, room not affectedCheck that building-work risk is not excluded
Group together in a refuge roomPartial renovation of the homeLocked room, away from water; declare the move
Entrust to a specialist storage facilityStructural work, long duration, absenceTransport + storage cover, climate-controlled, guarded premises

The "I'll put everything in the back bedroom" reflex is rarely the right one if that room adjoins the work area or houses water pipes. Conversely, climate-controlled, guarded professional storage is often the safest solution for a valuable collection during a major renovation — provided the cover follows the artwork into those premises. Collectors who live surrounded by their pieces would do well to plan this decision when getting quotes for the work, not the day before it starts.

If a loss occurs during the work

Despite precautions, accidents happen. A few reflexes determine a good settlement. First make the area safe and throw nothing away: a damaged artwork can still be appraised, and the debris documents the loss. Photograph the damage from several angles, in context. Then notify the claim to your art insurer within the deadline set in the policy (often five working days, sometimes two for theft — to be checked). If a contractor is involved, report it to their liability insurer too, without delay.

Never entrust a restoration to a non-specialist to "fix it quickly": clumsy work worsens the damage and complicates the appraisal. Let your insurer appoint a qualified conservator, or approve one with them. Finally, bear in mind the notion of depreciation: a restored artwork can retain a loss of value even after a successful repair, and a good policy covers it. For the step-by-step procedure, see our article on reporting a claim on an artwork.

FAQ

Does my home insurance cover my paintings during building work?

Partly, and often poorly. Home insurance caps "valuables" and pays out at market value, with frequent exclusions linked to building work. For a valuable piece, a specialist agreed value policy is far more protective.

Should I tell my insurer before starting the renovation?

Yes. Building work changes the insured risk and must be declared, ideally two to three weeks beforehand. Specify the nature, the duration and where the artworks will be kept safe. Failure to declare can reduce compensation.

Does nail-to-nail cover apply when I store my artworks elsewhere?

Yes, that is precisely its point. Nail-to-nail cover follows the artwork continuously: taking down, transport, temporary storage, then reinstallation. Simply check that the declared storage location is covered.

Who pays if a workman breaks a sculpture?

In theory, the contractor's liability insurance. In practice, fault has to be proven, the limit may be insufficient and the process drags on. Your own all-risks policy compensates you without waiting for the outcome of that claim, then seeks recovery from the party responsible.

Should the collection be appraised before the work?

It is strongly recommended for important pieces. A recent appraisal sets the agreed value, and a dated photographic inventory establishes the prior condition of each artwork — two decisive assets in the event of a loss. You can request a quote to arrange this cover before the work begins.

Have your collection's value agreed up front.