
Two policies can list the same artwork, the same value and a similar premium — and leave you, on the day of a claim, in two radically different positions. Everything hinges on a line people rarely read: the basis of cover. "All risks" or "named perils"? Behind these two terms lies the most decisive question in your policy: who has to prove what, and what is left for you to bear when the unexpected happens. Understanding the difference means avoiding the nasty surprise of a damaged artwork the insurer refuses to pay for because the accident was not "on the list".
Two opposite approaches to cover
A fine art insurance policy can be built on one of two architectures, and they work in reverse of each other.
Under named perils (also called "specified perils"), the policy sets out a closed list of covered events: fire, theft with forced entry, water damage, natural disaster, for instance. If your loss matches an item on the list, you are compensated. If it does not, you are not. The burden of proof lies with you: it is up to you to show that what happened fits one of the boxes provided.
Under all risks (sometimes called "all risks except"), the logic is reversed. The policy covers any accidental physical damage, whatever its cause, with the sole exception of what is expressly excluded. You no longer have to prove that the accident matches a listed peril; it is for the insurer, if it wishes to refuse, to show that an exclusion applies. The reversal may seem technical. It is decisive: most damage suffered by artworks is not spectacular catastrophe, but knocks, falls and handling mishaps — precisely the kind of incident a list of perils struggles to foresee.
Named perils: protection à la carte
The named-perils basis has one virtue: it is easy to read. You know exactly what you are buying, event by event. The perils commonly listed cover the bulk of "classic" losses for a static collection:
- fire, lightning, explosion;
- theft and vandalism, usually conditional on forced entry or an actual assault;
- water damage and seepage;
- recognised natural disasters and events.
The downside lies in what the list leaves out. A canvas that slips off the wall and tears, a frame knocked during a house move, a sculpture toppled by a visitor, an artwork that "disappears" with no sign of forced entry: these very common situations often fall outside the cover because no named peril describes them. The collector then discovers that their own clumsiness — or someone else's — was simply not in the policy.
This basis mainly suits simple, stable risk situations: artworks that do not move, kept in a well-protected place, with a premium budget you want to keep in check. As soon as the work is handled, lent, shipped or exhibited, the list quickly shows its gaps.
All risks: covering the accident, unless excluded
All risks is the basis most specialist fine art policies opt for, and that is no coincidence. By covering any accidental damage as a matter of principle, it matches the reality of actual losses, where the unforeseen outweighs the catalogue. It is the foundation of an all-risks agreed value policy: the artwork is protected against accidents in whatever form they take, and its settlement value is set in advance, with no argument at the time of the claim.
"All risks" does not, however, mean "unlimited". The real scope is found in the list of exclusions, which marks the boundary of the cover. It almost always includes:
- inherent vice: the intrinsic fragility of the artwork, its natural deterioration, an old restoration that gives way. Insurance covers accidents, not ageing.
- wear and tear and gradual damage: craquelure, yellowing, progressive alteration of the material;
- inadequate packing or handling that does not comply with the policy's requirements;
- war, seizure, confiscation and certain political risks;
- intentional damage by the policyholder.
Reading an all-risks policy therefore means reading its exclusions closely: that, not a list of perils, is where the true extent of your protection is decided.
Side-by-side comparison
The table below sums up the contrast. Premium indications are given by way of example for illustration: the real cost depends on the insured value, the risk profile and the covers chosen, never on a fixed rule.
| Criterion | Named perils | All risks |
|---|---|---|
| Principle | Only listed events are covered | Any accidental damage, unless excluded |
| Burden of proof | Up to you to link the loss to a named peril | Up to the insurer to prove an exclusion applies |
| Fall, knock, mishap | Often not covered | Covered, unless excluded |
| Unexplained disappearance | Rarely covered | Frequently covered |
| Clarity of scope | Clear, closed list | Defined negatively by its exclusions |
| Premium level (example) | Generally lower | Generally higher |
| Suitable profile | Static artworks, simple risk | Artworks handled, shipped, exhibited |
Remember the most important row: the burden of proof. Under named perils, doubt works against you; under all risks, it works in your favour. For a valuable artwork, this asymmetry often matters more than the difference in premium.
Which basis for which profile
The right choice depends less on the value of the artwork than on its exposure to risk — literally and figuratively.
For a private collector whose pieces stay on their own walls, a named-perils basis may suffice as long as the collection does not travel. But as soon as they lend a work, have it restored, take it to a second home or handle it themselves, all risks regains the upper hand, because it is precisely these moments of movement that produce the most claims.
For a gallery, an artist who exhibits, an auction house or an institution organising loans, the question hardly arises: artworks are constantly on the move, pass through many hands, are hung and taken down, shipped and stored. All risks is the norm there, often combined with continuous nail-to-nail cover. Handling risk is too central to be entrusted to a closed list.
The same holdings can in fact fall under both approaches: the static core under named perils, the travelling pieces under all risks. A specialist broker helps you draw that line work by work rather than aligning everything on a single formula.
Points to check before signing
The basis of cover is only the first line. Three settings determine its real reach, and deserve to be read before you sign.
The insured value. An all-risks policy loses much of its point if the value is not agreed: the insurer could then dispute the amount after the event. Have an agreed value set work by work, on the basis of an appraisal or an invoice, to remove that uncertainty. Exclusions and deductible. Two all-risks policies can differ sharply depending on their exclusions and the amount left for you to bear. This is the point to dissect first; our guide to exclusions and deductibles in fine art insurance details the clauses that drain cover of its substance. Limits and conditions. Check the limits per artwork and per claim, the security conditions imposed (alarm, safe, escorted transport) and how unexplained disappearance is treated. Cover that looks good on paper can be neutralised by a condition that has not been met.Before deciding, it is wise to have both bases compared for your specific situation: a simple fine art insurance quote lets you weigh the difference in premium against the difference in protection, and make an informed choice.
FAQ
What is the real difference between all risks and named perils?
Under named perils, only the events listed in the policy (fire, theft, water damage…) are covered, and it is up to you to link the loss to one of them. Under all risks, any accidental damage is covered unless expressly excluded, and it is up to the insurer to prove that an exclusion applies. The burden of proof is reversed.
Does all risks really cover everything?
No. It covers any accidental physical damage, but always includes exclusions: inherent vice, wear and gradual deterioration, inadequate packing, war, seizure, intentional damage. The real scope is therefore found in the list of exclusions, which should be examined clause by clause before signing.
Is a fall or a mishap covered?
Under all risks, yes, unless specifically excluded: an artwork that falls, gets scratched or breaks by accident is covered. Under named perils, this type of loss is most often excluded, because no peril on the list describes it — hence many unpleasant surprises.
Is all risks always more expensive?
Its premium is generally higher than that of a named-perils policy, because the cover is broader. But the difference depends on the insured value and the risk profile, and it is often modest compared with the protection gained, especially for artworks that are handled or shipped.
Can I combine both bases for the same collection?
Yes. It is common to insure a static core under named perils and reserve all risks for pieces that travel, are lent or exhibited. A specialist broker helps allocate each artwork to the basis best suited to its actual exposure to risk.