
When a work of art hits the road, it is tempting to assume that if it is broken or lost, the carrier will pay. That is almost always wrong. The law caps a carrier's liability at a few tens of euros per kilogram — a sum with no relation to the value of a painting or a sculpture. Understanding that limit is the key to understanding why dedicated transit insurance is not a nicety but the only safety net that genuinely protects your work's value.
Carrier liability: real, but capped
French law looks owner-friendly at first glance. Once goods are handed to a professional carrier, the carrier is presumed liable for loss or damage occurring during transit: it is for the carrier to prove it was not at fault, not for you to prove that it was. For damage noted on arrival, the principle works in your favour.
That is not where the problem lies. It lies in the amount the carrier has to pay. To protect a transport business whose margins are thin relative to the value carried, the law and the international conventions cap the indemnity. And that cap is calculated by weight. A work of art is, by nature, light and expensive: a painting of a few kilograms can be worth hundreds of thousands of euros. The legal cap then becomes derisory.
Three further traps compound this limit: the carrier can escape liability by invoking the object's inherent vice (fragility, an old support), inadequate packing supplied by the sender, your own fault, or force majeure; damage occurring outside the strict carriage phase (handling, interim storage) often falls outside the regime; and no depreciation after restoration is taken into account. Good reasons never to confuse "carrier liability" with "protection of the work".
Domestic transport: the standard-contract cap
For domestic road transport, where no written contract provides otherwise, the general "standard contract" (contrat-type) appended to the French Transport Code applies automatically. It sets indemnity caps calculated per kilo, with a per-package maximum.
Under the standard contract in force, for a consignment under three tonnes the indemnity runs to a few tens of euros per kilogram, capped at roughly one thousand euros per package (illustrative example: €33/kg up to €1,000 per package). Do the maths on a work: an 8 kg painting insured for €200,000 would, on total loss, be compensated up to the per-package cap — a fraction of one per cent of its real value.
A recent ruling made the point bluntly: hearing a dispute over the movement of a work valued at more than a million euros, a court held that the clause capping liability at €1,000 per package applied, the internal move being treated as an operation ancillary to transport. It is a first-instance, fact-specific decision — but the lesson is clear: absent any special stipulation, the cap prevails, whatever the object is worth.
International transport: CMR, air, sea
Once the work crosses a border, the international conventions set the caps. They too are calculated by weight, expressed in SDR (Special Drawing Rights, the IMF's unit of account, worth, depending on the rate, roughly €1.10 to €1.25).
| Mode of transport | Applicable convention | Legal cap (by weight) |
|---|---|---|
| International road | CMR | 8.33 SDR per kg |
| Air | Montreal Convention | 26 SDR per kg (since 28/12/2024; 22 SDR before) |
| Sea | Hague-Visby Rules | 2 SDR per kg or 666.67 SDR per package (whichever is higher) |
Here again, set these figures against a work of art. A 10 kg painting carried by road within Europe falls under a CMR cap of about 83 SDR — barely a hundred euros. Air transport is a little more generous per kilo, sea transport hardly more. In every case, the gap with the insurable value remains vast. These caps can be raised by a specific declaration (see below) or set aside where the carrier is guilty of wilful misconduct or inexcusable fault — but proving such fault is slow, uncertain and costly.
For an overview of the modes and their specific risks, see our reference guide on fine art transit insurance.
Declared value: useful, but not insurance
You will sometimes be offered the chance to raise the cap through a declaration of value (in domestic transport) or a declaration of special interest in delivery (under CMR or by air). The principle: you declare a higher value, pay a surcharge, and the legal cap is pushed up accordingly.
It is better than nothing, but make no mistake: a declaration of value is not insurance. The table below sums up the difference, which is decisive.
| Criterion | Declaration of value | Ad valorem (transit) insurance |
|---|---|---|
| Nature | Raises the carrier's liability cap | Insurance contract covering the work itself |
| Trigger | The carrier's liability must be engaged | Pays on damage or loss, with no need to prove fault |
| Excluded causes | Inherent vice, packing, force majeure release the carrier | All-risks cover, save a limited list of exclusions |
| Scope | Strict carriage phase | Nail-to-nail: handling, storage, installation included |
| Basis of settlement | Declared value, argued at claim time | Agreed value fixed in advance, no debate |
| Depreciation | Not taken into account | Covered under the contract |
In other words, a declaration of value acts on the cap, but leaves every one of the carrier's exits intact. On the day of the loss, you still depend on its liability — and on its ability to escape it.
The real protection: ad valorem, nail-to-nail, agreed-value cover
The right answer for a work of art is not to beef up the carrier's liability, but to insure the object for its value, regardless of any fault. That is the role of ad valorem transit insurance ("to the value"), built on three mechanisms.
All-risks cover protects against all accidental damage and theft, bar a precise and limited list of exclusions. Nail-to-nail cover insures the work continuously, from the moment it comes off your wall to its installation at destination, with no gap between stages — including during handling and any interim storage, precisely the moments when the carrier's liability is most open to dispute. Finally, agreed value fixes the settlement amount in advance, by mutual agreement: on total loss, there is no haggling over value at the worst possible moment.This is the architecture of an all-risks policy at agreed value, which can be taken out annually for a collection that moves often, or for the exact duration of a single shipment. The detail of continuous cover is set out in our article on nail-to-nail cover. It is the reflex of the professionals who move works daily, from auction houses to specialist shippers — a world we support as part of our work with auction houses and art shippers.
Securing a shipment, step by step
Protecting a work in transit does not come down to the carrier's reputation, however serious it may be. A reputable professional is subject to the same legal caps: its quality lowers the probability of a loss, not the amount the law lets it pay you. Here is the sequence to follow.
- Set the value. Have a defensible appraisal drawn up or updated, then adopt it as the agreed value in the contract. It is the foundation of any proper settlement.
- Take out ad valorem, nail-to-nail cover for the shipment — annually if the work travels often, one-off otherwise. Do not rely on the carrier's liability alone.
- Document the condition. Insist on a joint condition report at departure and on arrival, backed by photographs. It is the evidence that will settle any dispute.
- Get the packing right. Professional packing protects the work and denies the carrier a ground for release; our advice is gathered in our guide to packing and the transit crate.
- Check the scope. Make sure handling, lifting and any interim storage are covered, and not left in a blind spot between two contracts.
For a specific shipment or a collection that moves regularly, you can request a transit insurance quote tailored to your works and their journeys.
FAQ
Is the fine art carrier liable if a work is broken?
Yes, it is presumed liable for damage occurring during transit, unless it proves a ground for release (the object's inherent vice, inadequate packing, the sender's fault, force majeure). But its liability, even once engaged, is capped by law: the fact that it is "liable" does not mean it will compensate the work at its value.
How much is the carrier's indemnity capped at?
The cap is calculated by weight. In domestic road transport, the standard contract limits the indemnity to a few tens of euros per kilo, with a per-package maximum of around one thousand euros. Internationally, CMR caps at 8.33 SDR per kg, air at 26 SDR per kg, and sea at 2 SDR per kg or 666.67 SDR per package. For a light, high-value work, these amounts are out of all proportion to the real price.
Is a declaration of value enough to protect a work?
No. A declaration of value raises the carrier's liability cap, but it does not change the nature of the regime: the carrier's liability must still be engaged, and it can still escape it. Nor does it cover handling, storage or depreciation. Only ad valorem insurance protects the work for its value, whatever the cause of the damage.
Do I need insurance if the carrier is a reputable specialist?
Yes. A serious art carrier greatly reduces the risk of a loss, but it remains subject to the same legal caps. Its quality affects the probability of an incident, not the amount it is required to pay. Ad valorem insurance remains the only way to guarantee settlement at the work's value.
What is ad valorem transit insurance?
It is insurance that covers the work for its agreed value ("to the value"), on an all-risks, nail-to-nail basis, regardless of the carrier's fault. It pays as soon as there is damage or loss, without your having to engage the carrier's liability or argue over the value at the time of the claim.