Cimaise
Loans & exhibitions

Auction house insurance: consigned property

·7 min read·The Cimaise team
Interior of a gallery and salon where works are on view ahead of a sale

An auction house lives with an insurance paradox: every week it handles goods that do not belong to it, sometimes estimated at several hundred thousand euros, during the days or weeks between the consignor’s deposit and the hammer. A painting falls during the public viewing, a sculpture is scratched while being unpacked, a piece of jewellery vanishes between the office and the saleroom: who pays, and on what value? The answer does not lie in professional liability alone. It is built, phase by phase, around the consigned property.

A risk that cannot be reduced to liability

Many operators believe they are covered because they have taken out professional liability insurance. It is necessary, but not sufficient. Liability cover compensates a third party when the auction house has committed a fault: a wrong attribution, a missing caveat in the catalogue, a lack of diligence on provenance. It does not respond to accidental physical damage to a consigned object when no fault is shown — and that is precisely what happens most often.

Two logics therefore coexist, and both are needed:

  • Professional liability, which answers for the consequences of a fault towards the seller or the buyer.
  • Cover for damage to consigned property (often called cover for “property held on behalf of third parties”), which compensates breakage, theft, fire or water damage while the object is in the auction house’s custody, regardless of any fault.

It is this second form of cover, modelled on an all-risks agreed-value policy, that truly protects the property passing through the saleroom. It concerns first and foremost auction houses and fine art transport professionals, whose business consists of holding high-value goods on behalf of others.

Consigned property: who bears the risk, from mandate to hammer

It all starts with the consignment mandate (*mandat de vente*): the seller entrusts an item to the operator, who acts as agent to estimate, present and sell it. Throughout the mandate, the auction house is the custodian of the object. This custody carries a duty of care and security: article L. 321-5 of the French Commercial Code (Code de commerce) requires the operator to take all measures to ensure the security of the sales entrusted to it.

The risk period is longer than one might think. It covers:

  1. Collection transport from the seller, then delivery to the auction house.
  2. Storage before the sale, sometimes for several weeks.
  3. Appraisal and handling (unpacking, catalogue photography, framing).
  4. The public viewing, the moment of greatest exposure to theft and damage.
  5. The sale itself and handling in the saleroom.
  6. Storage after the hammer, until the buyer collects, which can take a long time.
  7. The return of unsold lots to the seller.

The question “who pays” depends on the agreement. Some houses charge the consignor an insurance fee based on the estimate (for example a percentage of the high estimate — purely as an illustration, around 1% to 2%), while remaining custodian. Others build the cover into their own policy. In both cases, the classic weak point remains the same: goods withdrawn from the sale or awaiting return are often less well covered, or even excluded. That is where a loss hurts.

What the law says about the operator’s liability

In France, an operator of voluntary auction sales is a commercial company registered with the Conseil des maisons de vente (the French auction regulator); it is not a public ministerial officer. Its activity is governed by articles L. 321-1 et seq. of the French Commercial Code.

Two points shape the risk. First, article L. 321-14 provides that the operator is liable, towards both seller and buyer, for payment of the price and delivery of the goods sold — a mandatory liability that the conditions of sale cannot exclude. Second, case law is consistent on the duty of diligence: the Cour de cassation (France’s highest civil court) held (judgment of 18 January 2000) that an auctioneer’s intervention carries the obligation to verify that the seller legitimately holds the objects and that export rules are complied with. A missing caveat in the catalogue, where there is doubt over attribution or value, can make the operator liable to the buyer.

In other words, the same object can trigger two losses of different kinds: physical damage (it falls) and a liability claim (it was fake, or wrongly described). Comprehensive cover deals with both. To understand how compensation works on the buyer’s side, our article on insuring a work bought at auction sheds light on the other side of the relationship.

Finally, to operate, the auction house must show that it holds insurance covering its professional liability and a guarantee for the client funds it holds on behalf of third parties. These regulatory obligations are a foundation, not complete cover for the objects themselves.

Agreed value or estimate: on what basis is a claim paid?

This is the crux of the matter. In the saleroom, three values coexist, and you need to know which one the insurer will use in the event of a loss.

Basis of settlementDefinitionBenefit for the auction houseLimit
Market valueEstimated market price on the day of the lossReflects the marketDisputed after the event, competing appraisals, delays
Sale estimateLow/high range in the catalogueEasy to documentNot a contractual settlement value
Agreed valueAmount fixed and accepted in advance in the policyFast settlement, no debate over valueRequires a serious estimate upfront
Agreed value offers the most protection: seller and insurer agree an amount in advance, which will be paid without further discussion if the object is destroyed or stolen. For a unique item — an old master drawing, a piece of silverware — it avoids undervaluation and a battle of appraisals at the worst moment. The catalogue estimate, by contrast, is there to sell, not to compensate: it does not bind the insurer. Basing cover for consigned property on an agreed value, reviewed for major lots, is the safest practice.

Watch the deductible and the per-item and per-event limits: a public viewing sometimes brings several million euros together in a single room. A badly calibrated “per loss” limit can leave a considerable share to the auction house in the event of a fire or a multiple theft.

Building the right cover: a five-step approach

  1. Map the flows. How many lots, what combined value in storage, on view, in transit at any given time? The peak exposure dictates the limits.
  2. Separate the two risks. Check that the policy covers both damage to consigned property and professional liability, with no grey area between them.
  3. Close the time gaps. Make sure collection transport, the post-sale period and the return of unsold lots are included — these are the usual blind spots.
  4. Set the values. Put major lots on an agreed-value basis using a documented estimate; link the insured inventory to the sale management software.
  5. Decide on deductible and recharging. Decide what remains with the auction house and what is recharged to the consignor, transparently, in the mandate.

A broker specialising in fine art insurance can translate these flows into cover and negotiate limits suited to the sale calendar. You can request a quote to have your auction house’s cover reviewed.

FAQ

Must an auction house insure the objects consigned to it?

It is legally their custodian throughout the mandate and must ensure their security. In practice, it takes out cover for “property held on behalf of third parties” covering theft, breakage, fire and water damage, the premium for which is sometimes recharged to the seller.

Is professional liability insurance enough?

No. Professional liability compensates a fault (wrong attribution, missing catalogue caveat) but not accidental physical damage with no fault. Cover for damage to consigned property must be added to deal with accidental breakage or theft.

On what value is a consigned object compensated?

That depends on the policy. The catalogue estimate does not bind the insurer. The safest solution is agreed value, an amount fixed and accepted in advance, which avoids any appraisal dispute after a loss.

When is the risk highest?

During the public viewing, when many valuable lots are gathered and accessible, and during handling (unpacking, framing, saleroom). Collection transport and the waiting period after the hammer are also frequent blind spots.

Who pays if a lot is stolen before the sale?

If the auction house is custodian and properly insured, its insurer pays, then may seek recovery depending on the circumstances. Without suitable cover, the operator may be liable to the seller on the basis of its duty of care.

Are unsold and withdrawn items covered?

Not always: it is a classic exclusion. Check that the policy covers goods awaiting return to the seller and those withdrawn from the sale, which are often forgotten even though they remain in the auction house’s custody.

Have your collection's value agreed up front.